I think the Leeds game (Johns debut) was the best I've seen at the HJ for atmos.

Yes - have to agree with that for the HJ, but the very first game was special too.

For Wilderspool there were many games that were special.
v Saints when Davies kicked to Sullivans wing and simply destroyed him 20-0 up at half time - special.

Beating Wigan was always special - although it didn't happen too many times unlike now !

One of the best nights was at Wilderspool when we momentarily won the league even though the attendance wasnt massive.

Bouncing.

I tore my ankle ligaments when I fell off the increasingly crumbly terrace in front of the BB stand as everyone went mental for our last try at 'that game'!

It's a shame there don't seem to have been that many big days/nights at the HJ, but the opening night & Joey's debut were both pretty special. The lack of importance for regular season games, and the increased emphasis of season ticket attendees (and consequentially lower crowds at knock-out games) has led to this IMHO - however, at least we now have regular finals to look forward to, so it seems everyone is saving their voices for these

I went to watch FC United on Saturday in their play off final. If anyone wants to know how to generate an atmosphere, that's the place to go to learn. The crowd was 4500. Of which I'd say there were 2500-3000 FC fans. There was non-stop singing from half an hour before the game, right to the very end and beyond. Almost all the songs are originals and not ripped off from some other clubs. There were flags, scarves, smoke bombs and flares. There were kids singing, teenagers singing, middle aged and old people singing.

They went one nil down in the first minute, but the singing didn't stop. They went two nil down and there was no moaning or booing. Just more singing and support of the team. There was no retro day, no fancy dress, no drums, no copying what Wigan/Celtic have been coming up with, no Bermuda shorts, no wacky hats, no goal music, no face painted adults, No Helen Lovejoy deriding that there were smoke bombs, flares, swearing or fans on the pitch at the end and no ear splitting pre game music. Just support.

Good luck to anyone who wants to get together in an area of the ground and make some noise but I wouldn't expect it to spread to the masses of the South Stand. Warrington fans and Rugby fans in general just don't have it in them. Not when one of the opposition might be half a yard offside.

I don't think smoke bombs would go down too well though personally I don't see any harm in them what-so-ever.

I really don't get it at all. WHY? What do they achieve? It is a bit of coloured smoke which just gets in the way of watching a game, stinks and scares kids. Some plonker set one off near me in Wheldon Road last year, of all places. What did achieve? If they were hoping it would lead people into a passionate drum led rendition of Cas is a hole... it did the exact opposite. It just made everyone head for the gate instead of staying to clap the players off, and probably put a few kids off going to away games for a good while. Brilliant, lets turn the place into a smog filled bowl and throw a shredded copy of the midweek Guardian into the air, it will have the foundations rocking. Or people could just grow up, stop trying to replicate idiotic soccer fans and enjoy the standard of football which we are being treated to every week!

You really mean the second part of that statement, don't you?

If it was at the end of a game or before the start and it went off next to me I must say i honestly couldn't care less. I'm not saying I would personally set one off I'm just saying it wouldn't bother me.

Depending on which type of flare is used , they are either a) illegal to set off as they are intended to be used in an emergency (eg:- maritime flare), b) they are illegal to set off as they actually count as an explosive device or c) they are illegal to set off in a public place as they are a matter of public nuisance. Which would you prefer to argue to the judge?

No worse than the moron continually banging a big bass drum in the match vs Salford....not uplifting not inspiring just bloody annoying...We were in the north stand and goodness knows how much more irritating it must have been to those stood near him in the south stand.