An opposition coach complaining we were too tough....yep I will take that every week thank you.

Kind of throws out the argument you often here from other fans that we have no strength in depth.

Walne x 2.
Evalds.
Ashurst.
Walton.

Not bad deputies too have really.

I'd be interested to know your definition of a dirty player. Tasi has played one season in SL- just 19 games, he's conceded 16 penalties (the highest is 18 this season) but been cited three times already this season (late, high, shoulder charge-looks like he finally got one with all three!) that's more than murphy has been cited for in his whole SL career!
Ps I hope Locke is on the receiving end of a similar tackle. Let's see how your attitude changes then.
And 10 men- wow! Perhaps you should have been given Eorl and robbo were also taken out off the ball- stick to football pal- you can't know less about that.

Penalties conceded do not define whether a player is dirty or not, I would guess the majority of those are through being caught offside or lying on in the tackle. How many games has he missed through suspensions this season?

He's a kid in terms Super League props, highly inexperienced and will occasionally get things wrong. The referee dealt with he incident well and sent him off, no further 'justice' needed.

I've read your posts and thought that you make some valid points in a reasonable way. To WISH harm on a player to make a point is bang out of order. Your posts are also deteriorating into childish tit-for-tat which is doing you no good. Regardless of the incident, which has been dealt with to Hudds satisfaction (After all, he got a straight red which is the max punishment) Like you said with regards to Murphy and Johnson, if all the other Hudds players were 'taken out' then why haven't Salford players been punished for it? Using your argument, it must mean that they didn't do anything yes?

Do yourself a favour and stick to arguing with other Hudds fans, something that you seem to be good at. Because at the rate you are going on here, your posts are going to become embarrassing sometime soon.

any idea how much you contradict yourself? No further justice needed for tasi but wishing injury on murphy- a player who prior to this year had only ever been up before the disciplinary once in his entire career! Penalties are given against players who break the rules of a game. 3 times in 19 games is "getting it wrong" more than most. Even those inexperienced.

But you just did wish it on Locke. Do you suffer from short term memory loss?

We don't know whether they will yet- as the ref bottled one and put it on report. We will see tomorrow.

So he put one on report? But you said that Salford players had taken out half your side? Which means, by your own logic, that only another one incident (possibly) could have occured due to foul play. Your maths don't add up.

No further action needed. It was late, but it wasn't high. He deserved the red card, end of. Where did I say I wished injury on Murphy? I just said it was a shame it wasn't him in the receiving end as opposed to Brough.

Half a side? I said Eorl and robbo were also taken out late- one of those was put on report. The other may yet be brought up by the review panel.
My math is fine- I can subtract 1 away from 13 and get 12 not 10. I also know three isn't half of 17.