Utter , shocking shocking shocking. Leeds did not deserve to lose that. Handed the game to saints

Handed you the first half, us the second half!

He hasn't got the balls to make a decision - the last Sts try when Roby went over literally directly in front of him, and he needs to check the grounding???

As a neutral for that game I think that is about right.

Leeds got away with murder in the first half

Think that's spot on. The last two decisions were absolute shockers. But they didn't hand saints the game

agree, thought was equally good and bad for both sides.
correct decision to send moon off but soliola should have at least 10 minutes.

Well that's more the craziness of the rules...

Swinging arm with shoulder = penalty. Just the shoulder = red.

I agree it was a bad one though. I thought soliola had it out for my blood pressure at one point!

I dunno. The scrum to Saints was right, if the same incident against LMS was anything to go by. I don't think he much wrong tonight. The red card was an automatic red, a true brain explosion, and he did well to refer that onwards. With other referees that would have ended with Leeds players slapping Moon on the back and the game carrying on.

It was well spotted and absolutely the correct decision. you're also probably right about the scrum at the end.

Some awful clangers by silverwood tonight, all we want is consistency. Last few mins ball gets walloped out of sutcliffes grip, officials can clearly see the infringement but the on field ruling stands. Next play silverwood gives leeds head and feed, but when officials see the replay and the ruling gets changed.

And you wouldn't mind the sending off if they're was consistency. I'm sorry but if the player didn't get ko'd from moons shoulder it would have been play on. And how is a player falling on a shoulder in a 4 man collision worse than a player totally taking out a player who had kick the ball well before he was committed to the tackle.

The Sutcliffe ball strip should actually have been play on - Hohaia stripped it out one-on-one and the ball went backwards.

The last minute (Ganson call?) that Aiton played the ball was absurd, and there were a few other really easy calls they got wrong.

Falling on a shoulder? Moon went in with the shoulder. He made no attempt to use his arms to tackle. Pathetic excuse.

Really? This is Wakefield level of silly suggestion. Ganson isn't a ref. he can't make a call. It was a wrong call yes (especially after the lms one had been deemed not played at) but as I put on my first post here, there's quite a few decisions in the first half that were more than dodgy in Leeds' favour. The penalty for Watkins knocking on, Leeds getting a penalty for trapping Walmsleys arm, Jamie Peacock holding Roby on top of him for a penalty etc. Difference being those were in the first half not the last minute I suppose ...

I'll give you watkins and walmsley, but you can't seriously be suggesting the little love grip peacock had on roby's wrist kept him on the deck, no other part of his body made a move away from peacock. He smashes trough 120kg guys week in week out and can't make an attempt to move away in that scenario.....come on!

You lost credibility for throwing that one in. Also remember the 2 points for saints first penalty was a knock on.