Are you talking about defensive positioning by chance? It's the one failing he never really improved on whilst at Hull

Partly positioning although in fairness every winger gets caught out at times. It was more a question of his having the quickness of thought and the decisiveness to try make amends once he had been caught out. He was very flat-footed at times the other night and his confidence seemed to wilt visibly once things started to go wrong. A good team would spot that in no time and exploit it ruthlessly.

As fan of a club who has no players in contention for the wing (maybe soon though), I would go with Hall, encumbant England winger who has done nothing to loose the position. I am not worried about his try tally as playing outside Moon he has not needed to score. McGillvary must play as he is the form winger in our competition & should be given the spot on that alone(I would have Cudjoe at centre with him). If we take four in the squad then Briscoe & Burgess if three Burgess, & it is a shame a couple of other contenders will miss out.

If McGillvary is that good, it makes you wonder why the Sydney Roosters didn't go for him rather than Joe Burgess...

BTW who is England's #2 goal kicker (after Widdop, presumably)?

Sam Tomkins? I've hardly seen him kick a goal in the NRL (although he does do restarts, and the Warriors do get plenty of them...).

How do you know they haven't?

Jack Reed probably.

Which is exactly why briscoe is a better winger than hall. He can create tries out of nothing and puts himself in the right places to get the ball whereas hall pretty much hangs around on the wing waiting for it

Mc Gilvary is so good Wigan want him !!!!

Despite some of our more excitable supporters Hall is No 1 for me still.

Then it is a toss up between Mc Gilvray, Hall and Burgess.

McGilvray if we are playing the power game and the other two if we are going down the attacking pacy wing play.

But it will slos come down to who are the centres.

Wings and centres should be picked together on how they complement each other.
NO good picking two players who individually are good but dont click.

I'd agree with most of this. Except I don't think Hall is mobile enough to play on both wings

He's played on the right against the Aussies when Slater popped out his shoulder when Hall got 2.

I think Omar was making a joke about a mis type


I found it funny anyway.