I was listening to the game on radio during last night's game, so I filtered most of the commentary out. Thankfully.

Agree. People call for Bill Arthur, yet he has the personality of a goldfish.

Eddie proves value for money. Just now in the Wakefield v Bradford match.

"Platt was perhaps a little high on Cockayne then". Superb stuff.

Stevo has annoyed me a lot tonight with his unprofessional-ism.

The 'banter' with Brian Carney is making my teeth itch.

You can hear Carney responding through gritted teeth; I think he spends lengthy periods feeling embarassed by his fellow commentators.

Absolutely he does, I feel embarrassed for them too and with good reason. I can understand people liking the energy and enthusiasm they bring to the games, but the pair of them know nothing about the game any more and interrupt each other with pointless statements. The coverage is a real mess at the minute and would benefit from a more professional approach.

Do you not watch much NRL?? Think your getting rabs and gus mixed up mate. As for been hyper critical never heard it myself, will say when a ref has made a mistake but gone go on and on about it for 10 minutes!!

I've watched virtually every NRL game on Premier Sports for the past two seasons, but I have to admit that I don't watch it with the same attention that I do domestic games. I may well be getting the names mixed up, but there's certainly one who plays the 'grumpy old man' and often pits himself against his fellow commentators in extended bouts of comedy banter; it gets a bit wearing, just as Eddie and Stevo's inane ramblings do.

Has Jamie Peacock got an MBE? Only I don't think Eddie mentioned it.

I vote cod'ead for overlord of rlfans. Cracking idea!

The key difference between our coverage and the Aussie coverage, is that when a ref calls a player/captain over to talk - they shut the hell up and listen. Eddie and Stevo ramble on about the slightly off-green colour of the grass or the cous-cous they ate when SL kicked off in Paris, then when the player runs back in to the line they scream "well I wonder what that was all about .. he's obviously just had a word with him about something" .....

Stevo must be the worst commentator of RL ever, he's so out of touch it beggars belief.
Never played Super League and boy does it show. He's so so out of touch with the modern game,
just retire him and send him back to Aussie where he's obviously happy.

They are out of touch and lack basic knowledge and make things up to suit there own argument.

On boots n all they were banging on about Gentle and Sandercock and said that no head coach from australia had come to super league since John Monie. So Nathan Brown was not a head coach then when he came across.

When commentating they go off on there own little agendas and ignore the game.

I'm not one for jumping on a bandwagon, but I think Stevo should be put into the studio. You could cut and paste the same commentary from every game as he only uses about 20 different sentences.

I don't honestly know who i'd replace him with, I like Jon Wells and Brian Carney, Tony Rae used to be superb too, far better than Paul Cullen.

Eddies good I think, and I like Graham Beecroft too, good addition.