If you consider the inconsistency around the issue it's understandable, in the same game that MM got sent off Perry got away with dropping on Lima with forearm but didn't "promote" the arm - yes, from standing up to dropping on someone's head without promoting the arm?? One punch for Wigan = sending off, but for others not so much.

Don't be silly. McG attempted a rather dirty attack and got hurt himself. To say that McG has a great record is a fallacy looking at his playing style, he gets away with a lot.

Not necessarily. If the referee was unsighted then on-report was the correct decision, thats what it is there for.

As it is I dont think either will be banned, both looked lazy rather than malicious.

If they do get banned however, ill just accept that as a difference of opinion between me and the disciplinary panel, rather than some crazy conspiracy where the RFL are trying to engineer a Leeds GF win by banning Mike bloody Mcilorum.

no. it could be they didn't get a great look at them. although in this case there was a clear view for both.

And if they don't does that mean they got it right? I doubt you'd see it that way.

Need to calm down, inconsistencies and chance only have meaning when you make stories up to rationalise randomness. The ref's performance was shoddy and more money needs to go into it quite frankly, but we all knew this before.

This is the exact point that is the issue. Inconsistency. Just last week, 1:30 to go, ah well, lets just let it go.

If it's the worst refereeing performance where's your assessment of the Catalans infringements. You have ignored them! Why's that?

Hmm, so you're argument is that two different things not being judged the same means the judging of incidents is inconsistent? Strange

dirty? pulling a player back? first week of the following season tommy leuleii (sp) did the same thing. difference is he was in a wigan shirt though

McGuire deserved a red. He went swinging and connected with the side of the head - it was a disgusting challenge. Fakir should have gone too.

Burrow's knock on at the scrum should have been picked up. Peacock's offside/not square should have been picked up too. Two atrocious decisions that went against the Catalans.

I feel very sorry for them. Inept refereeing cost them big time.

not the money but the man in charge

they got 3 times the penalties Leeds did.

If McIllorum received a ban from the disciplinary panel, does that mean the officials on the field got it right?

And?

Does that make it all better that the officials missed the incidents they did?

And McG wore a Leeds shirt but also did more than pulling back.

Money = More men to choose from/better training = Better men chosen = Better refs = Better product.

Unfortunately, this would probably mean a net loss in terms off money (improvement in quality of matches probably wouldn't translate to cover costs) so unfortunately it's not a decision likely to be made.

Did he? What else did he do in that incident?

Yes. I've never defended McIlorum's challenge.

No, it just makes an argument that the referee favoured Leeds a clear nonsense

A- wrong.that was all he did
B- does that justify people wanting him to have his career ended?

Embarrassing refereeing and the amount of forward passes and lying on from Leeds was ridiculous. And what a moaning set of pussies they're turning out to be.

Thaler should be kicked down to amateur level until he sharpens his game and grows some balls.

viewtopic.php?f=28&t=537524&tsmp=1348262045 Anger and bitterness taken to a new level. Oh no not quite a new level actually, after all some Wigan fans have gone further in the past.

viewtopic.php?f=28&t=537524&tsmp=1348262045 Anger and bitterness taken to a new level. Oh no not quite a new level actually, after all some Wigan fans have gone further in the past.

So you genuinely believe that Danny McGuire does not deserve a ban from the RFL for that challenge tonight?

Let's roll reverse. Had Kevin Sinfield made the challenge Mike McIlorum made a couple of weeks ago and received a red card and a three match ban, then a couple of weeks later Gareth Hock made the challenge Danny McGuire made tonight can you honestly say that you would be of the same opinion and would be vehemently denying the claims of inconsistency that fans are making tonight?

You, sir, are talking utter !

Any way, regardless of Wigan bitterness and Thaler, i thought it was a great game, some great skills, Catalans have some big tough forwards and played their part well, Leeds kicking game was the difference in my opinion, Sinfield best player on the field, was making some big hits right until the end and controlled Leeds really well.

Leeds were lying on and Catalans weren't??!! Wow. Dislike Leeds by all means but talk sense in doing so.