Aaah - but imagine how good Hull could have been had they signed Tyrone McCarthy. It's an inspired move by hudds IMO

I am confused have the Giants signed Tyrone Power or Rick Wakeman ?

Haven't made a mistake I'm purely talking about how you wrongly regard players - which is arrogant - the schematics of the thread concern me little.

Your over estimation of your team may well come crashing down around your ears this season as is the Hull way, then you can tell us all how individually brilliant and top eight your players are.

How utterly magnanimous of you.

You did ,this part of the thread was about Huddersfield signing Wakeman poor old Tyrone McCarthy was used as an example of an average player been a star player in the NSW comp you've jumped in thinking we're slagging him off thinking he's signed for Huddersfield when it was a Huddersfield fan comparing stats to an NRL players stats and a Hull fan pointing out you can't compare the two comps

If you say so but that wasn't the point and you know it.

I don't know. Maybe someone like Jordan Thompson? You know those squad players in the Hull team?

McCarthys better than Washbrook for a start.

That was exactly the point I don't know how much clearer I can put it just admit you got the wrong end of the stick and we can all move on

Not a fan of Thompson, don't think he will be in the 17, which is what I said.

Total disagree, wasn't sure about him signing, but was excellent last year for us and played a big part in our success.

dont forget, he left wakey to come back to fc, so he is deemed poop by most previous clubs fans






anyway, if wakey sign mcCarthy, the rest of SL wont have a chance with their 'monster pack' lol

Yes because Hull fans have never slated players that have left their club before have they?

Think majority of Wakey fans were sad to lose Washbrooke when he left.

How many other clubs did he play for to be deemed poop by his other previous clubs' fans'?
and fwiw not many Wakey fans thought he was poop


As for Wakey's perceived monster pack, is there a hint of jealousy there old girl

Tyrone McCarthy played Dual Reg for Leigh in 2010/2011 (Wire parent club).

He was decent at Championship level & benefitted Leigh at the time but IMHO he was upper Championship level/low SL level at best.

Championship in 2010 & 2011 was nowhere near the standard of 2015/16.

He may go well, he may flop, who knows ?

TYRONE McCARTHY IS NOT COMING TO SL HE WAS USED AS AN EXAMPLE OF AN AVERAGE PLAYER

Nope- a Huddersfield fan did NOT compare stats.

you know you're in a classic rlfans thread when you have to go back 6 pages to find a post relevant to the thread title

Apparantly this is a point you can't make - because the fans of the one season wonders say so. Funny how Hull fans get all high and mighty after a CCup win created for them by what seem to be superhumans.

Be funny to see them in meltdown after the first ten games of the season with only an opening day win against Wakefield to comfort them. At that point they will again be awoken to the fact that they are a club without a winning heritage and will thus never be able to compete with proper clubs like Wigan, Saints or Leeds.

It's not a point you can make because he's not coming to play in SL and I'm a fan of the Hull team that got relegated just happen to agree with the fan of the other Hull team

Most wakey fans (yourself included) would give their right arm to have just one season like we have just had before they die

Not sure about an arm, maybe a little toe.

They have 12 I hear so shouldn't be a problem