have you some examples of anti ginger murders?

I think you have missed the point. Cas didn't get fined because the chanting was homophobic, they were fined for failing to take steps to prevent or stop abusive chanting. The chanting aimed at Graham was abusive and contained foul language, I'm questioning whether Leeds had taken steps to prevent this or respond to it?
And to make it clear, I do not condone any abusive chanting. However, nor do I condone unfairness and in this case the procedure should be the same.

And it seems google don't have any reports but there have been a few news reports of ginger haired people being killed for being ginger./committed suicide on the back of hate campaigns.

Quote: SmokeyTA "I think you have missed the point. Cas didn't get fined because the chanting was homophobic, they were fined for failing to take steps to prevent or stop abusive chanting. The chanting aimed at Graham was abusive and contained foul language, I'm questioning whether Leeds had taken steps to prevent this or respond to it?
And to make it clear, I do not condone any abusive chanting. However, nor do I condone unfairness and in this case the procedure should be the same.'"

This, don't control your crowd get a fine, the precedent has now been set, stick to it RFL.

so no then?

Take it you never watch the news then? and did Leeds control the crowd? no because there were at least 4 offensive chants throughout the game lasting far longer then the "15 seconds combined" at Cas, and in far larger numbers.

read the rfls respect campaign and you will find that it is abuse.

has somebody who has been on many rfl courses including their anti bullying course its taken very seriously at junior club and can have massive repurcussions for any club or person found guilty of bullying.like ive said on another post they have opened up a can of worms and only have themselves to blame because they made the rules and they after act on them if their are any complaints.

and? there is no law against not being offended

i take it the news you watch is filled with stories of people being murdered because of being ginger but it being reported nowhere else

nobody has said bullying is ok

There are laws against bullying & discrimination, which ginger chants fall into both, and did Leeds try and stop it? you can't answer that one can you? the RFL have set the bar now and they have to do it for every club, Leeds did nothing to try and stop it, that is now a fine based on what happened this week.



Stop trying to justify the chants then

it doesnt, you are incorrect.

Yes it does, you are incorrect.

Do people get suspended from school/work for abuse of gingers? yes, because it is offensive, abusive and bullying, is there an RFL anti bullying law? yes. Did Leeds do anything to try and stop the chanting? no.

this doesnt mean that chanting that graham is ginger is the same as homophobia, and as such doesnt require the same response.

You have just created yourself a little circular argument that proves nothing other than your inability to understand degrees of offence and the power of certain words, which is quite frankly ridiculous

Cas were not fined for the homophobic chanting, they were fined for failing to stop it. Leeds did not stop offensive chanting, so under the same interpretation, that is a fine because Leeds FAILED TO CONTROL THE CROWD, that is what the fine should be for, NOT THE CHANTING.

And how can you say, really, that a ginger person doesn't find chants about him, by thousands of people more hurtful then a gay person does about gay chants, by 15 people, for a combined total of 15 seconds? You're the one who cannot comprehend the degrees of offence caused here.

abuse is abuse the same has murder is murder end of. try telling a verbally bullied ginger fat kid its any different to a gay man been verbally abused its exactly the same and you know it is any decent lawyer would take the rfl to the cleaners.

In this modern free spoken society
There is a word that we still hold taboo
A word with a terrible history of being used to abuse oppress and subdue
Just six seemingly harmless letters arranged in this way will form a word
With more power than the pieces of metal and that are forged to make swords
A couple of G's (GG) an R and an E an I and an N
Just six little letters all jumbled together have caused damage that we may never mend
And it's important that we all respect that if these people should happen to choose to reclaim the word as their own it doesn't meant the rest of you have a right to its use
So never under estimate
The power that language imparts
Sticks and stones may break your bones but words can break hearts
A couple of G's (GG) an R and an E an I and an N