I'll be the first Northern fan to say Lionel Williamson on Trevor Lake.
How good? The game was more than 40 years ago but I am sure I will not be the only Northern fan to put this tackle as the greatest ever.

Don't know about the best, but the worst was Shaun Edwards on Mal Meninga at Central Park, it looked like a lad on his dads back.

just noticed 100th post

The Gary Connolly one on Domic is on youtube under "top tackle" From the camera angle, it looks like he comes from nowhere.

Craig Richards (Bradford Northern) on Kelvin Skerret (Wigan RL) 1990, Odsal Stadium, Stones Bitter Championship, Richards knocked him into orbit! plus we beat the pies by 1 point in 61, cracking game!

Paul reilly try saving tackle in the 2006 cc final against saints!

Just watched it. And even back then Stevo’s commentary was as bad as it is now – instead of praising the great tackle he says of Domic ‘he’s bombed it, I have never seen anything as bad as that from an experienced player’ (as he didn’t pass to the inside man)

I wish we had commentators who talked up the game