I'd be happy with an end of season knock out featuring the current boundaries that allows West Yorkshire to play against Cumbria and Lancashire and Merseyside or whatever. Teams should be picked on birthplace rather than where you first played and certainly no Irish Grandparents dog's best friend's cat's mother in laws rule to be allowed.

A little unfair seeing how the Merseyside representative team just be St Helens minus all their overseas and non-St Helens born players.

East meets West

The key to this is the RFLs stance on it being an England trial and that players who pull out from the game can't play for their clubs in the next round.

Sell! Sell! Sell! the idea to the fans with some smack talking, get players to talk about where they came from and which amateur clubs they started at. Give the freaking tickets away dirt cheap to ensure a big crowd and build the concept over a few years instead of the passing commitment that we usualy get.

This idea won't go away for a good reason, theres something in it but we just need to nail it down and make it work!

Still doesn't make it true though : State of Origin was pretty much an instant success and has never looked back.

One big reason was that, in the old NSW v Queensland pre-Origin games, NSW could call on all the Sydney players, even those born in Queensland. This meant that the contests were becoming increasingly one-sided and losing their appeal. Suddenly when Origin arrived, all the Queenslanders who had followed the money to Sydney could play for their home state again and give the cockroaches a good walloping.

Second big reason was that since the mid 1970s, GB has rarely been able to challenge Australia's international dominance and New Zealand hardly more often. So State of Origin increasingly (and probably rightly) became regarded as the pinnacle of RL competitions world-wide.

Compare that to our situation and we have neither of those factors. The old county championship died out through lack of interest and the Wars of the Roses revival was barely any better - especially since only one side gave any impression of really caring about the outcome.

Sorry but I don't have the answer, but I don't think Lancs v Yorks or East v West or any such variation will do the trick since not enough people actually associate with either of the sides (especially on the west of the Pennines).

Sorry....wrong..The players east of the pennines, Yorkshire, were far, far superior to those from West of the Pennines, Lankashire. That's why Yorkshire were victorious...Ok?
Ok, lets run with this

Personally I'm not that bothered about identification with the teams, I just want to see the best that RL players in this country can play. I'm sure I'd pick a team after time to support (it makes it a little bit better) but for all I care they could call the teams Reds and Blues and flip a coin to see which players are eligible for both sides.

(Although I will add that if there is something, anything to get up for - East/West Lancs/Yorks that would be preferable)

For me its got to be a three match series North (SL players born in Northern England) v South (SL players not born in NE e.g. Pat Richards etc) played at Venues in either the East or West Midlands on the same day as the Origin Series.

I would keep the Magic Weekend but have it either as the first or last game of the weekly rounds, venue & country to suit the time of year.

It could work, I would want East V West so not alienate anyone, unless we had it three ways Lanc's York's & the rest. All should be England/Wales/GB qualified. A good cash reward for selection (not in the salary cap) & make it a condition that to play international you must play in the seires also make it plain that this is the the selection for any international team. Also as posted if you pull out of any game you will not be able to play for your club that week unless the RFL doctor verifys the injury. If you could get a sponsor by all means give season ticket holders a free game but I would charge, If fans wont pay they dont deserve any consideration,

This idea will never EVER work so I really don't understand why we are debating it.

It will NEVER happen.

EVER.

Lets draw a line under it and move on


Here, I'll draw one ok??



-------------------------------------------------------------------- < A line

Cos Yorkshire v Lancs would really set the fans on fire, I can see Catalans Dragons, Gateshead, Toulouse, Whitehaven, Barrow, Workington, London Skolars, Crusaders and Quins RL fans queing up all night long for tickets.

When the game would be Yorkshire vs the Rest and the tickets are included in the purchase of your season ticket then why would you not want to see the best 34 European players play against each other.

The 2010 All Stars match down under drew 27,000 paying spectators. If we can't get people to go along to fill a 40,000 plus seater stadium when they get it included with any rugby league season ticket then rugby league is too snobbish for me.