maybe we should have a poll? bit like X-factor - who should go neither,either or both?, certainly be more entertaining than reading their drivel

Who would you vote for Mat?

Im not trying to sway the votes or anything guys, but just remember that that Simac is a Saints fan, and just remember that he's a bit...you know.

Go to PM please, children?

Mike - come on...you really ought not to get suckered like this!

I've heard this used to be a rumours thread.

No confirmation though.

Hey Adey. I like winding Simac up.

Indeed, but you don't want to get banned as well? This iteration of you is quite likeable, after all, and it'd be a shame for you to go down in the wreck when someone FINALLY gets fed up of thread after thread being derailed due to a common denominator?

Well, it wouldnt be the end of the world. But OK, enough for now.

If - and I SINCERELY hope not - Chase joined either the Bulls or the Rhinos he would be widely accepted as a "World Class Player" within the first half-season there.

Losing Shenton and Westerman was disappointing - if Rangi left Cas it would be absolutely catastrophic for the club.

In 20 years of watching Cas I've never seen anything like him - the guy is mesmerising and I hate to admit that over the last two seasons almost every game we've won he has been instrumental.

No he wouldnt, because he's not world class.

Given a straight choice now, i would love us to sign Chase if possible. Whilst this is pure speculation, so is everyone else mentioned whether it be Pryce, Monaghan or anyone else quoted by so called 'people in the know'.

As it stands at the moment starting next season with Herbert & Chase sounds damn fine to me

I would sign Chase tomorrow if he became available. I can imagine few SL clubs that would not, given the chance. Academic though, cos it won't happen.

I would aswell. But that doesnt mean he's world class. He's a good player, no doubt. But world class. No chance.

Mike, I heard a rumour you thought Chase was not quite what one might call "world class".

You tend to keep your opinions on players pretty well to yourself, as all the world knows, but maybe this once you could make an exception and tell us what you really think?

I think he's a good player. I dont think he's world class though.

Only that a) doesn't matter; b) illustrates why you are a fan and not anywhere near a coaching field and c) contradicts the very people at Cas who watch him every week and seem to feel he genuinely is.

No matter, he won't be at Odsal next season so it's a futile topic. Whether there will be a new 6 also remains to be seen.

It doesn't matter to me wether he is or he isn't. Not bothered in the slightest.

Your upteen posts on the very point, suggest otherwise.

You bite more than your favourite singer Cheryl Cole. And that takes some doing.

You were the one that took the bait, Julien. Even if it was intended for Cas fans.

More surprised you can tear yourself away from ya Pot Noodle, XBox and beating one out over Cheryl Cole to type.

Admirable what fattys do these days. Probably get a Government grant for it.

Woahhhh, Graham. How dare you.

Me, X Box and Pot Noodles?

No way.

PS3 and and Steak.

Will someone just ban these two clowns already?
They've already ruined two threads with their tiresome bickering, don't let them tarnish this one as well.

Yeah ban us.

"I'll take one for the team"

Bet youve said that a few times eh, GB?

just ignore them, everyone else is

................................................................