Wayhey!!! Just been reading up on him and he's only ever scored one try throughout his career at senior level. So Ancient Provocatuer will be happy that'll make him a shoe in for the nude run.

See my post on the other thread. There were no stars, but I would have taken Snitch, Fozzard or Haggerty over him, and would have felt we'd done no worse with Matt James, Feather or Jackson.

King Thackray and Moore would have been better aswell imo.

Moore was not OOC. Personally, I would prefer Sculthorpe as a player to King and - although he's probably a better player than DS - I wouldn't want Thackeray anywhere near Odsal.

I think, given that list, I would have opted to keep James if that was possible.

I think the retention of James would have pleased most out of the options presented

Thank you so, so much for taking Sculthorpe! Our pre-season just gets better each week!

Awful.

Brilliant!!!!!!

Best laugh i've had in a while!

I know for a fact now that even if you could afford to table a bid for Brough no club could afford there is no way he would play in the same team as that "waste of skin".
So that's another to cross off the list.

More world class signings from our wonderful "Coach" Who the hell did we beat off for his signature? Dudley Hill? Richard Moore would have been money better spent! Oh and how the hell is he "Plugging the gap left by Sam"????? Well size wise maybe? But then again I could have filled that gap!

I think this and the other below answer why this is such a bad signing. I would have preferred the do nothing option and promoted from within.

Maybe retained James, tried harder with Cherryholme

I had picked up indications (from outside the club) we were looking at props at this level. This isn't a signing that immediately excites me, must admit, and indeed I find it a bit puzzling. Could say we have been here before with Chris Feather? Sculthorpe does have talent with the ball, without doubt...but will we see enough of it? I hope we do.

Happy with the Reardon signing. Have to reserve judgment on this one. What I will NOT do is get on a player's back until I've seen him out in a Bulls shirt a few times and seen whether he deserves either the shirt or the shîte. Maybe one or two others could do worse than do likewise?

See Macca has effectively confirmed Hall will play second row then, since he excluded him from the list of props he named?

yes, we are now a laughing stock for bloody Wakefield fans. This is now where we are at.

Great work Agent M. Now bugger off.

In case you can't readRichard Moore is not OOC! Ok!

This signing was always going to polarise opinion though