saves me typing exactly that , I agree.

Radford and Langley

Mackay and Forshaw. Langley has been a great servant and loyal but the other two were more skilful.

I agree with tigs analysis of McNamara.

You beat me to that observation & I think you are being somewhat kind in saying they were merely more skillfull than Langley
Other than the superb physical and tackling attributes required of a loose forward, they had a vision of the game going on around them and the handling skills and pace to dictate that game.
Criminal to decide who is in the team and who is on the bench, or even left out altogether.
Mackay just edges it for me

Since working in Donny you have become erudite & perceptive. Strange that.

Easy,

Len Casey,one of the hardest men ever to pala the game of rugby league.

McNamara and Mackay for me.

I like my loose forwards to have more of a creative bent, hence Macca (I would have thought Forshaw achieved a higher standard through his career). He'd have fitted into that dominant pack perfectly.

You have chosen Brad Mackay as the best Bulls loose forward ever.

Mike Forshaw got your nod for the runners up spot and will go to the subs vote.

Ken Traill