Very very lucky, catalans won this game by a mile tonight but unfortunately the referee's saw it through red & white glasses, poor refing again.

The Meli one was pathetic. But that dissalowed try was literally the worse decision ive ever seen. Catalan should have won that one.

I see josh perry is still a waste of space.

Josh Perry played well I thought, the first penalty was harsh he was on him for 4 seconds at the most. Another penalty for a 'high' tackle was over the shoulder. He was poor for Catalans first try, lazy defence. Apart from that he played well.

The officials in rugby league make me sick to the core but to suggest that the French would have won this game by miles is a very silly suggestion!

The Trolling skills are weak in you young padawan ...

Well that's me put in my place sir, im'e not the messiah im'e just a silly boy!

Shocking video ref decision.

As for perry head high all night.

An even game for me but Catalan shaded it.

If you watch the kick again, you can see the Catalan player jumps no where near the ball his jump is entirely timed to knock Makinson. If he was challenging for a ball, then he needs to actually get near the ball not just jump into a man.

I agree it's a 50/50 call, but sometimes they go for you other times they don't.

However I see from your massive 12 posts you missed all the poor calls Saints got.

Keep on Trolling...

It's a shame we are talking about the ref when we've just seen a top class exciting game.

I understand the challenging for the ball, but seriously when he jumps he gets no where near the ball, he's already coming down before the ball hits makinsons hand.

I can see it both ways and yes it could have gone the other way, but for me if you are challenging on a kick you have to actually go for the ball and not just the man.

Tommy fluffed it, get over it and move on!