Ok. Of our first 17, who did we have on the field tonight?

Wellens
Gidley
Gardner
Meli
Graham
Roby
Clough
Puletua
Flannery
Wilkin
Fozzard (since we lost Maurie yonks ago and he's been playing quite a bit since then and he isn't exactly a debutant)

Our only totally inexperienced player was Gaskell and I felt sorry for him as it was a bit of a baptism of fire to do your debut but I was glad to see him get a try and he worked hard.

Lomax is a regular, when he is fit, and he played well.

Ashurst has been playing very regularly this season.

Moore has played in every match this season in one position or another either for the full 80 or as an interchange.

In effect, we were missing Cunningham, Pryce and Eastmond. Soliola has been gone for the season so we haven't missed him and Maurie has been gone so long that his absence no longer affects us, with Fozzard as a poor replacement but still a direct replacement.

We missed a creater and organiser. We still had enough experienced players out there to win or at least to be able to pass, catch and tackle, none of which most of those players could do tonight with any reliability. I really don't think injuries could be an excuse tonight. We have played far better with far fewer experienced players in our side. We played far better after we lost three players against Leeds last weekend.

hands off Millward !!!

Fair enough, potter has to take some of the blame but also the players need to take the blame as well.

Tonights team was good enough and should have beat Catalan but potter shouldn't take all the blame. He don't miss the tackles, he don't drop the ball, that is basic skills that these players at times this year can't do!

It's not Potters fault he's got to many players that ain't good enough.

Tactics and game plan shouldn't be needed against bottom of the league.

If potter should be sacked now then a few players should go with him.

Indeed. Potter's bizarre interchanges and screwing up the whole team as opposed to just the halfbacks didn't help but we had enough fire power out there to at least challenge the basement dwellers. However, we were never in that match. What a ridiculous waste of two points.

Potter picked a team that was good enough to beat catalan. Even if they all played where they like and with no game plan we should still beat a poor Catalan side.

The players are as much to blame.

s'up lad....can't sleep?

Fretting I suppose!

Um, which youngsters are you talking about? There was Gaskell, Lomax, Dean and Ashurst out there last night. Unless you include Moore as well. Dean was a turnstile, it has to be said, but Wellens wasn't much better. In fact, none of them was. None of them could tackle last night. Lomax worked hard though.

Damn right it was, which is why it is so annoying that we didn't even bother competing much less trying to win.

Can't believe all this slagging off of players and coach as we go through this transition period compounded by one of the worst injuries situations on record.

Can't believe no one has mentioned anything about Ian Smith who always referees us in to this type of non flowing anti rugby game, we only win 1 in 3.

Can't believe people thinking the Catalans should be beaten by any side we put out, bottom of the league, but these past 3 weeks they are playing with form.

Think you should all get over it, we lost, we move on and support the team and hope we get our best 17 ready and in form for the play offs.