Chris Finch? Did they sign him off the terraces?

A blind dog that walks round sherdley as picked up the news Shenton and Perry have signed for Saints. I'll ask one more time. How do 'YOU' know more than his agent ?

If its not Meninga then Meninga's former boss Tim Sheens would do nicely.

To be fair To Rogues, he hasn't actually said he knows more than his agent, Just stated he doesn't believe he will come over. Mal's agent has said he would consider it, not that he'd come.

Take the bet if your sure, makes things more interesting. I should know, I lost £100 to one of their lot last year! Although it went to a good cause.

Thank you. It's nice for someone to read what is actually written and not what they assume was meant.

Seriously? I've been away for a couple of weeks and this news would kick them holiday blues right into touch.

Brett Finch is a good organising half back who has played State of Origin. He was superb for Melbourne v Bulldogs over the weekend.
I'm not 100% sure if his signing is true but I have heard from it from two different sources, as far back ad the Murrayfield weekend.

The general concenses from people who know him as a player seems to be that he's good, but not great. Imo it sounds like he'd be a good "old head" play alongside Tomkins.

I have a different opinion. I watched him live last season for Parra when he didn't have an orgainisng half back with him and he was utterly atrocious. The Parra fans at the game were calling him not fit to burn and Anderson got rid of him a week later.

There's plenty of players who have played Origin who don't necessarily make good imports.

Will it looks as though the Masked Magician has decided not to take up the bet, although I would have expected him to have the decency to accept or refuse.

We'll just leave it there then shall we, with the bet off.

Stop fishing Brian, you've caught enough this week.

I find it annoying we allow the likes of rogues on our site, yet we can't touch cherry and White.

they let me on with no bother

They don't let me on, and i can't remember why, or if i did anything, it was that long ago!

That's because you post reasoned arguments / discussions in a well though out manner without offence.

They ban anyone that trys to have any banter. I'm pretty sure that i wasn't offensive towards anyone, yet i was banned. I'd have expected a PM if i was offensive to anyone. You have plenty of banter on here, without a banning, maybe that should be re-considered though!

Should blend right in at Wigan.

Just noticed McClennan's post... dammit...

It's the price we evolving humans have to pay.

You really are an annoying bugger aren't you?
And your'e not even trying at being annoying; your just a natural.

You are repeatedly avoiding the question by repeating your childish mantra of "a somple you or no will do" you your pathetic "bet".
All he wants to know why you think your opinion is of more value than what Mal's agent has said. The owning of shops etc is a junk reason which his Agent would surely already know about when he said Mal would consider coaching us.

Has Meninga's agent said that he will definately take the job? No, he's said he will consider it. RG doesn't think he will. Do you know what prompted the statement from the agent?

Why does that mean that RG thinks he knows more than Meninga's agent? The agent wouldn't be doing his job properly if he dismissed it out of hand before receiving an offer, even if there is no intention to take the job unless a ridiculously large sum was offered.

Rogues said he 'definately won't take the job. His agent is stating otherwise.

He actually said:



His agent stated that the role would be considered, not taken.

How is that stating otherwise?

I see Rafa is leaving Liverpool. With a much bigger job available at Saints, it can't be a coincidence.

You need to look up the definition of definite, particularly as the word definately does not exist.

If you had said probably then you would have been correct. There's a huge difference.

Is anyone aware of a bookmaker offering odds on your next coach? I've heard a whisper today and i'd like to stick some fiscal on it.