He’s also barely played any games in the last 12 months hardly a recipe for finding any form. It’s a problem that exists right through from the academies with some players being held back in their development through simply not enough/any game time.

I get thats he hardly played but im asking what potential do people see in him that i cant see that if hes given a run in the team he would offer anything??

because he's had the odd really good game and someone saw enough to give him a long term deal.
let's have a look before we sign someone from outside is surely a no brainer. especially as this season's a write off anyway.

I am sure nobody at the club has written this season off yet.

Which shows how out of touch they are unfortunately. There is a very fine line between confidence and arrogance.

if Leeds can get past Leigh, get a good s/f draw then Wembley is possible. the GF? not a chance for me

I agree but Leigh is a big hurdle IMO with our current form and injuries. IF we were to get past Leigh then the SF draw everyone will want is the winner of Huddersfield and Catalan but again on current form both those teams would be a much bigger challenge for us than they would have been 3 months ago

An ugly win on Friday and then hope our form improves throughout June and July ready for an August semi-final and hopefully final. Our only hope of silverware this season.

I agree, but if he gets 5-6 game run now with all the injuries and side on the back foot, we still won't know allot, give him 5 games in a side competing and on the front foot and that will tell us more. On form alone good as moon is he does not deserve his starting place when fit, I personnally think Lilley should be in the 17 somewhere from now untill season end then decide whether to keep him or not. Certainly miler looked pretty dangerous playing a bit wider on Saturday and having that bit more space, in that alone lilley gives us that which moon does not.

Myler has played on right edge most of the year. He was no wider Sat bur spent most of his time on the left.

As far as I can recall Lilley only ever had a run of games during the disaster which was 2016. Giving him a few games when the team is playing almost as badly and expecting him to shine simply isn't fair - the club should either ditch him, which would be odd given the contract he's signed, or give him a chance in a team thats going OK. I've no idea whether he'll ever amount to much, but only playing him sporadically and in different positions when most of the team around him is playing awfully is a recipe for giving him no chance at all.

If Moon is back this week he will be straight back in at 6.

no improvement then. and the ineffectual handley stays at 4.

Who was heavely involed in two trys wt the weekend one a superb effort.

Ineffectual he may be, but far more tries scored through left wing/centre than before he moved there.