Widdop is Brilliant ? not even sure he is good , but brilliant is certainly an overstatement

I said Widdop "for me" is brilliant. So yes, IMO, he is brilliant, and by far Englands best player of the series. Like I said above, England desperately lacks a proper scrum half.

Williams was a threat when he came on, why didn't he start, Percival had a nightmare day but will learn from the experience and come back stronger, biggest cheer of the day was for a punch replay

And some wonder why I questioned if Gotcha exaggerates his appraisals when he said Ward was "excellent" vs HKR the other year,

It's a shame daly cherry-Evans doesn't want to switch allegiance, with an English mother

That would be the same Widdop who changed the whole tenor of the game vs the Kiwis when he put a restart out on the full which arguably led to them getting back into the game against us
The same Widdop who in that same game failed to demand the ball for a drop goal attempt when we were bang in front of the posts.
And the same Widdop who when we were starting to gain some much needed momentum in the first half today failed to find touch with a penalty kick, again inviting the Aussies back into the game.
I'm not saying that we would have won either of the games but his unforced errors were not the play of someone having a brilliant series of games.
He took his try well, but then so did Hall & McGillvary.
Cameron Smith ran the game for the Aussies & it was hard to see what Bennett brought to our game that McNamara didn't do last year.

Agree, bang average, Williams has that certain something and made the Aussies think twice when he on

Clarke and Houghton in to pace up the ruck area, sneyd in to bring a kicking game in, must be worth a try

Oh look Printer wanting to start a bickering again, surprise surprise.Still going on about a match nearly two years ago that made him look a fool on here. As said many times, the same excellent repeated by the coaching staff at the time, but disputed by the armchair radio listener. You don't do yourself any credit highlighting your own error.

Agree about the hookers. Totally underwhelmed with our 9 today. Those who watch him in the NRL could perhaps help me out, because from what I've seen he has no pace, passes most of the time behind or in the face of the runner and when he does run tends to run up his own backside.

he was bang average today, couldn't find touch ffs, As its important to you to get the full perspective were you there?

And that is your opinion, and entitled to it. Mine is that you are wrong, and equally I am entitled to that.