What makes this year's choice so difficult is that most of our stars have missed games yet the side generally has not suffered unlike in previous seasons.
But Cuthbertson has I believe added another dimension to our play thereby reducing our previous reliance on Peacock.
For that reason he would get my vote.
But I have no quibble with all the other suggestions.

McGuire, Aiton, Cuthbertson or Ward are the front runners for me. The question from there is whose absence would have affected us the most, and I'd probably have to say McGuire or Aiton. Very tough to call this year though as nearly everyone seems to have had some really good periods.

Mags for me...run close by Cuthbertson and Aiton

To date

1. McGuire
2. Ward
3. Cuthbertson

All the contenders have already been mentioned.....but it had to be McGuire for me who is having a real Indian Summer.

We genuinely have 5 or 6 players that could be player of the year and there wouldn't be many complaints complaints. That shows how good a team we have been. Add to that the massive improvements from Keinhorst, Singleton and the emergence of Handley and the future doesn't look bleak

After the season so far, and especially last night, Cuthbertson for me. Last night he was a rock. quality offload, neat passing. In some drives it was quite obvious he wasnt looking to make metres on bash down the middle, drawing players in and getting that second phase going.

For me I cannot look past Cuthbertson. Has been a quality signing for us. Gets stuck into the tackle, good athlete, does the hard yards and combines that with some good passing at the line and a quality offload game, something we have sadly missed since Ali left. I read today he has already achieved the most offloads in a SL season with 97, and the season is far from over. to compare Ali best season was 81 offloads. Most of them are quality offloads as well. Been very impressed with him

I think we've seen some excellent performances from quite a few of our squad tbh the likes of Handley Sutcliffe and Singleton have stepped up and proved their worth and that the future is in safe hands.
Tom Briscoe started like a house on fire ,Hardaker has easily proved he's the best FB in SL bar none ,Moon has gone up another level ,Aiton is all quality and Ablett overall is having a decent year.
However like many others my top 3 are S.Ward ,Cuthbertson and Mcguire and id be happy to see any of them get POTY but Cuthbo shades it for me.

1-cuthbertson
2-aiton
3-mcguire

After last night's game Cuthbertson definitely went up the pecking order..... what an inspired excellent signing he is proving to be.

Just hope not too many start targeting him (especially with those damn cannonball 3rd man in tackle incidents).

Cuthbertson is top of the offload chart for the whole league with 97.

To put that in perspective, 2nd and 3rd place Taia and Tomkins combined have 91 (47 & 44 respectively)

I don't recall watching much of Cuthbertson in the NRL.Its said his offload game didn't go down too well with coaches down there, however watching him for us this year there is so much more to his game than just throwing offloads at any opportunity.He has great hands, a deft touch, gets through a ton of work and i can certainly see comparisons with James Graham.Maybe he just needed to be let off the leash i don't know but he has been outstanding for us and wouldn't look out of place playing test or origin rugby playing like he has this year.

The ball for Singleton's try - and the set up play of organising the runners that went into it - was the brain and skills of a half back in a prop forward's body.

That NRL coaches didn't want Cuthbertson to play to his strengths says more about the dull, turgid nature of their competition than it does about him. He'd be one of the first names on an England team sheet come the autumn for me. Imagine him, James Graham and a Burgess on the field at the same time. More than a match for anything the Kiwi middle unit has to offer.

He's already broken the SL record for offloads in a season with nine games still to play. In terms of a Leeds player of the year, it's Cuthbertson then distance then the rest for me.

Cuthbertson has better hands Graham IMO. If he wants to play for England, then he should be a shoe-in.