You're confusing biff with niggle.

That's all well and good but for 80 minutes our forwards couldn't get near either of their halfbacks due to their forwards dominance.

Niggle is an essential part to kicking the Biff off. And to be honest there wasn't much niggle in the England team either

Biff usually needs at least 3-4 incidents of "niggle" to precipitate. We had about that number of incidents of "niggle" before Senior gave Wilkin the slap a couple of seasons ago. However, in internationals it was traditional that the only thing needed to intiate major biff would be the first scrum (I'm sure some players would knock on deliberately in the opening 5 minutes of any test match just to get going).
There were enough scrums in the England - Australia game for the English forwards to sort things out had they so desired. Having said that we would have needed to ressurest the likes of Fred Lindop to officiate, any of the softco*k generation of refs we have now would have abandoned the match. These "Dougie Howser's" of the RL world are too gutless to red card near decapitations yet would be totally unable to grasp the concept of international biff.

Worst of both worlds. High shots "put on report" , biff outlawed.

well said, but in the england team there were only two maybe three players I have seen "sort things out2 and unfortunately there about duw a pension.

Was it not a scrum that kicked the peacock fight of in the WWC?

Regarding Senior putting the jack of all trades squarely on his bottom, I recall him helping him up before putting him back down, anyway it got me thinking. Bailey did the same thing to Kevin Brown this year and there was outrafe.

On report should be scrapped at all levels but it makes absolutely no sense at international level. Will Isaac luke miss a game against england, no, it has nothing to help the team who was fouled.

If its bad enough to go on report, its enough for a yellow IMO
I believe reffs are scared, both of the aussies, and of spoiling the game and in regards to biff giving a sport with minute coverage a bad image. Thats why ganson should ref he dosent give two hoots what anyone thinks.

The problem is the ref's abuse the on-report system. It isn't supposed to be there as a cop-out but for when there is genuinely a case where the ref didn't see something. I cant recall which one but it was one of the internationals (think it might have been Wales v Australia but I could be wrong) where there was a bit of a scuffle just after a try and at the half-way line before the next kick-off the ref brought the 2 captains together and put the incident on-report. Thats fine by me, and is what the system was brought in for.
The Isaac Luke incident though was just a first class cop-out by a gutless referee. IIRC the ref even said to Luke "you deliberately tried to hurt him in the tackle". So the ref had seen the incident, gave a penalty but still put it on report. Ridiculous.

As for biff - we are sorely lacking it at international level for England, the only one in the series who looked up for it was Westwood. We need a Barrie Mac and Sculthorpe back, (or Morley in his prime) someone who the Aussies are genuinely wary of and who will dish out the biff at almost any opportunity.

Cop out pretty much sums it up and it becomes even more apparent at international level that that is the case.

I totally agree regarding your example of when it should be used but you'd hope that in general play between three of them ref and 2 flag men, they'd be able to see most of whats going on and not have to resort to report. The issue off useless touch judges however is for another thread.

Would there however be a way to speed the system up i.e. hand it to Video ref, then at least the team who was on the recieving end gets some out of it, rather than next weeks team getting an advantage.

Morely Barrie Mac
Peacock Brain Mac
sculthorpe
A fighting pack to be feared, not to mention senior in the backline. That wins half the psychological battle

A few years ago I saw an old video of an early 70s test. IIRC Rod Reddy bit Jim Mills; Jim reacted by nutting Reddy & snotting him a couple of times on the way down. Not one Aussie came anywhere near.

I'm pleased you mentioned that example.

It really is quite laughable to hear of the more modern examples of legendary hardness involving players like McDermott, Morley, Sculthorpe and Senior.

Pussycats compared to players from the 60's and 70's.

I forgot to mention, again IIRC, Lindop was the ref, he penalised the Aussies & just got on with it.