I thought that was Walters. Or Ferres. Or Sutcliffe. Or Ablett.

I don't think people dislike him as such but like many over the last three years he needs more consistency. One game he looks like he could be really good, the other he is bang average. If he can reach a level of consistently decent (doesn't have to be world class because he isn't and never will be) performances then he is a good squad member who probably isn't on mega bucks.

Load of Guff he's had plenty of gametime to improve & show his worth he hasn't done it simple as.
He like the other lummox you mention above is just taking up SC space we could use elsewhere & a squad spot we should be giving to another youngster.

lets hope he can sort his running style into contact out as he was very much on the radar of the disciplinary last season with a couple of bans and other warnings for his 'knees up' style.

I see your giving James Donaldson a trial

Do you ?

Yes

Can't see the harm for the club - but he wont play - if he does the likes of Cameron Smith wont

He's one of those players who will give everything & has all the core skills but is just not big enough. It's what frustrates me about players like Ferres who have it all, with the size, but just can't be assed half the time.