Archetypal FC fan responses to an opposing opinion.

Instead of dissecting and breaking down the opinion they prove themselves to be the muppets they are by either answering with another question of discrediting an opinion with no reason what so ever.

Had Pelissier played out his planned spell, then Catalans would have gone on to win the game comfortably because not only would he have capitalised on Catalans dominance of the ruck in the first 30mins and improved it with his lively, energetic and improvisational dummy-half play, Henderson would have also been fresh at the back end of the game.

Consequently, Heremia's performance would have been negated considerably and FC's go-forward would have suffered.

If you can't post a counter argument then you're welcome to concede that you don't have one.

Guess that must mean that I've won the debate then!!

Anyway, why don't you have a word with the mods on your board to lift my ban and I'll happily debate with the rest of you!!!

Sorry we spoilt your Friday night.

Are you mad? Henderson was great last night.

Our 7 was not playing either... Edited. JD

I enjoyed the game if not the result.

Either side could have won or lost it and that cant be bad for the game.

Some nonsense in this thread though !!

Agreed J, I felt confident prior to the game and was going to suggest we dropped the old daunting "in-joke" for this season and so felt even more confident during most of the first 40 yesterday

I thought we were looking good in patches, but the same old problems with discipline. Momentum changed and Hull took control, I thought Whiting was superb for Hull in that spell and I suppose we did well to claw our way back into the game.



New season, same old 'ull

Let's try a new thread title next week then

Taking a scythe to the internecine East Riding bickering.

Problem is, since we lost - is next week v cas genuinely daunting?

I have a new plan... Stand by.

The frightening thing is that Catalans were still in the game despite only winning around 10% of the rucks, even when leading in the first half, Hull dominated the wrestle and the Catalans 'peel' was virtually non-existent. This allowed Hull attackers straight up to play the ball without the Catalans defenders being set in markers or the defensive line. As a result we were always on the back foot and Hull marched us up the field repeatedly.

That we were still in the game (thank you Westerman) was a miracle in itself, had we snatched a point, I would have gone straight to the bookies to get the odds on Hull finishing outside the eight as to have so much of an advantage and not win a game is pretty much criminal.

all IMO of course.

We were drowning in it at Wembley and Huddersfield.

You really do post some rubbish. The determining factor in the game was the kicking conditions. If we'd kicked all ours we'd have won. If Bosc had kicked more, they'd have won. Simple as that.

Apologies for prolonging it!