I think a reality check from the FC fans that are trying to goad us,is in order. The fact is, beating Hudds last night and potentially beating any of the teams around us is doing us a favour, you now appear to be playing to your potential, and good luck with that. Some on here will bite, but the majority are more concerned with Hull KR playing well and trying to secure our S/L future not Hull FC playing badly.

Reality check?? so believing Tilse is a good player is reality? to think he is better than Pritchard is reality?. The reality is that some cannot take the fact of Fc being in top four and Rovers in bottom four ,how long that lasts i dont know but at the present time thats how it is.

At what point did I mention either Tilse or Pritchard?

They really didn't

Radford recruited a massive pack. He has one decent halfback (Pryce is a has been and never been stunning in his whole career).

This season FC are going well. Will they be able to do so when the interchanges are reduced by 2 next season? Time will tell.

If you agree the NRL is better than SL and that Pritchard is miles better than Tilse it's strange that tilse has played more NRL games than Pritchard the point I'm making is Tilse isn't as bad as people make out and for what it's worth I like Pritchard and comparing them as people have is pretty pointless

I'll give you Campese because he's injured but a star when he's fit. Tilse managed 36 metres against Franks 148 so no contest.

Our pack isn't really massive other than pritchard. taylor, watts, bowden and green can all do long minutes and our back rowers regularly do the full 80.

Rubbish forwards will still be rubbish though no matter how many interchages there are

Campese finished. If you look back to the beginning of the season I and a few others told you that. As for Tilse lol nowt to say.You've a poor team and need a clear out IMO. Plus getting rid of c Chester was a knee jerk reaction as is being proved. Theres rumblings behind the scenes and a lot of those are being caused by a certain person . interesting times at caravan park

What rumblings are you referring too? And from whom?

Rufus? although is he classed a person or a bird. thoughts?

Really? Good job they did otherwise you would have got hammered.

We did thanks to their fantastic kicking game and a winger who can't defend. Catalan are the best team we've played.

Catalan got put on a team penalty in the first half as when we finally got the ball they couldn't control the ruck. Our halves then did nothing with it.

Tilse and Campese get unfair criticism on here. I used Pritchard's 'efforts' as a comparison. He's up to a massive 98 tackles this year. My intention was not to reduce this interesting thread to the usual nonsense.

Our neighbours are prickly about Frank cause so far he's disappointed. They are going well and win without him. Not the same if Sneyd or Houghton were missing. Players they criticise unfairly. But enough of them we have enough problems.

Our response at Cas is important and will tell us a lot about Webster as a coach. We need to be the most motivated team in that game. If we aren't then things may get more unpleasant.