Is no one actually going to say the most obvious thing? We miss Dobson! It was the same against Cas. With that much ball in the opposition half we would have scored a fair few more points with Dobson in the halves than what we had. For me Keating isn't the answer and we need a more organising half rather than a runner. Look at what Sneyd has done at Cas and I bet he was a lot cheaper than Keating.

We all knew we would miss Dobbo. But i never realised how much we relied on him! Keating is gash, and needs to follow Sandy out the door. Would rather see Beharell given a chance.

think that's a bit harsh tbh, obviously he isn't dobbo, but I've seen enough to say he will be a very good signing. some good balls for the tries against wigan, a well taken try yesterday, not the perfect kicking game yesterday but most of the time Bradford were coming out from their own 10 pinning them in, so hardly kicked poorly. I think we played the conditions well yesterday, spectacular it definitely wasn't but a wins a win.

Give him a chance,had a decent game yesterday and kicking was average,but scored a good try and will only get better,was one of our better players against wigan,dont get like our duller friends and start looking for a scapegoat.

By his comments about him on The Super League Show Matty Smith obviously doesn’t agree with your assessment of Keating. But then again what would he know he only played against him

I've said on the other forum I can see sandercock been here a long time, however possibly in another role. He strikes me as someone who would make a very good director of rugby, overseeing the rugby side of the club from top to bottom with a first team coach in place such as Chester or Webster