I cannot understand the 'rules' on this, they are so vague, it takes a thread with 100's of posts on the interpretation, without success.

Released by us and now released by Celtic - I'd rather give a kid a shot. Might be 'fed-trained', but'd still look like we're going for a cheap antipodean option.

Thing is we aren't short of [inumbers[/i at prop even now. Vella, Lovegrove, Wheeldon, Mills, Watts, Netherton and, at a push, Newton can play there. 7.
Our universal comparators have O'Meley, Moa, Cusack, Dowes, Lauaki and, at a push Radford. Assuming King is going to leave, that is just 6.

Tangata-Toa or similar would add depth, when what we want is quality and a bit of impact.

I wasn't advocating signing him, just responding to a sarcastic post from a Duller.

I'd be very surprised if we didnt sign Kyle Bibb. As from the other side of the world im not sure, but the Clinton rumour seems to be the strongest at the moment. I wouldn't be surprised if the signing we WILL make though, is a bolter that no one has mentioned, due to them been under contract.

Borrowed from the ins and outs thread on the VT
Wakefield Wildcats

InTronc(NQC), Korkidas (Huddersfield loan);
OutWilkes (Quins), Drew (Huddersfield), Atkins (Warrington), Pitts (Leeds), Bibey (Leigh), Naughton, Brown (Featherstone), Rooney (Barrow) , Grix (Huddersfield), Winterstein (Celtic), Sculthorpe (Bradford), Martin (released);

2 props in, but 3 out at Wakefield. Would they be looking to offload another? We've got plenty so a swap deal might be possible - but the ones they are likely to want probably going to be the ones we'd prefer to keep.

Not

Could do worse then try and bring Seb martins back. Looks a good prop.

Wilkes is a second row.

I was thinking the same thing as he crashed over. However, his 4 game loan spell in 2006 wasn't extended due to his failure to settle outside France. I don't see him coming back to an English club anytime soon.

Big lad though, used to play centre as well

Was.

He has been playing front row almost exclusively at both Widnes & Wakefield.

I'd actually be delighted if Martins came back. The only reason he didnt stay last time was because of something to do with his girlfriend not wanting to move to England. he subsequently split from her and ended up at Leigh.

Jordan James has been awesome for the Welsh in the last two games.

Was thinking that. You could do worse than giving him a shot.

i agree with you, hes big, strong and has decent speed too, could do well for us.
but hes not the super star were going after lol

For me it would be James Graham and Sam Burgess.