That's true yeah but who knows with the rfl at least they have looked at them or is it cos it was on tv they knew they had to anyways they're still bent

If the rfl are serious about the new shoulder barge rule then they have to start setting examples starting with Wilkin and gardner . Having only watching the game once I cant remember much of the gardner one tbh but the Wilkin hit on Dobson was shocking . Why couldnt silverwood go to the big screen to look at point of contact ?

To bloody lazy and prob cos he knows he'd have had to sin bin him or sumet

They will both probably put an early guilty plea and cop a measly 1 game ban each ... The system works

The Wilkin one is deserving of a couple of games, but I genuinely think Gardner was committed and when Welham passed to his winger he was that shocked it caused him to turn into the tackle and lead with the shoulder. The fact that Welham finally passed to his winger was also the reason why Hodgy dropped it.

i like the last point there why are ref so quick to go to the screen for some calls but not others , in most games tv you can see players asking the ref to go to the screen ,sometimes they will sometimes they dont ,going back to your point iirc silverwood put the incident on report saying he did not see the point of contact.unless he didnt want to inflate gansons over inflated ego any bigger giving him bbc airtime.

Wilkin has been banned for 2 games, Gardner for 1 both submitted EGP's.

We've brought someone in on loan don't know who it is yet and welham our for four Weeks

We've brought someone in on loan but we don't know who they are?

Mike Smith signing that.

Ha ha no I just don't know somebody does just not me at the moment

Hall to left centre (his versatilty is so valuable at the moment!), Caro or Brown recalled, I guess.

A loan signing would be good. For all that Green and Beaumont have done okay-well, if it isn't a centre, I'd guess at a prop.

a centre / 2nd row type would be my guess, but I'm with you, switch hally to left centre which was arguably his best position at hull and bring browny back in on the right wing

it's Luke George who we've signed on loan and Jason netherton is back

He not getting much game time at the Giants at the moment? Pleased if true.

Netherton coming back would be an odd one - or do you just mean he is back in the UK?