You can tell Charlie loves the club and the club have shown great loyalty to him. I hope we are offering him a new deal as he's our best utility player. Doesn't hurt that the crowd love him either.

well of course he loves us as we are seemingly willing to forgive him any misdemeanour.
if was down to purely performances on the pitch then a new contract would be a must but with cockayne it isn't down to just that and we shouldn't have short memory's just because he plays well.
and as for legend. NO!. Clive Sullivan, Roger Millward, are we really putting ben cockayne in the same category as these true legends

No, and we should let him go. Ticking time bomb. Thanks for the performances but no new deal.

Legend? Surely that's an insult to the many 'proper' legends to have worn your shirt?

Think we should give him a one year deal and say prove urself if rovers were gonna get rid they had the grounds to do it on two occasions, so dont agree with u I say keep him and see how he goes.

I wouldn't say he is a legend he is a very good utility player for us with a bad reputation and controversy, if he gets a new deal which I hope he does I hope he proves himself.

I'm finished with him, he's dead to me. I feel ashamed to have contributed towards sponsoring him.

Everyone has diff views I can't see kr letting him go, and like I've said if they do re sign him it will be under strict rules, who knows what is gonna happen, he as done bad stuff let's wait and see

yes it is

Agree completely

I wouldnt go that far but to me the person off the field is as important as he is on the field when representing our club. So no deal for me.

If we let him go, he will get a new club. He is a good player with the heart of a lion and he always gives 100%. He has had his problems off the field, but so have lots of players in the past and will do in the future. I would give him a conditional deal for 12 months and if he keeps his private life to an acceptable standard for the club, then look at extending it.

agree

Thats fine and dandy but theres acceptable and acceptable. Even being caught in a nightclub after midnight would be enough for me. He's had his 9 lives.

The coach and board will make the decision and if Ben is a Hull KR player for the next few seasons then i will support him every time he pulls on the shirt.