So you started off saying you liked him and he's played well to saying he's lazy and won't be missed in the same post

I'm nothing if not contradictory!

So between the 2 worst clubs you've managed to pick one?

Both are useless because of poor recruitment, poor retention and chaos at board level.

Cory Paterson had to pick one. Wests are having a bad couple of seasons, Parramatta's been a career graveyard for years.

Did Parra offer him a deal?

Keal Carlisle signed new 2 year deal, turned down offers from Saints and other S/L clubs. Looks like Withers could on his home.

Good news if true. Quite like Carlisle and reckon he could really crack on with more game time. Withers does a good job but is pushing it a bit now.

Fantastic news. I truly believe that in Kiel and Josh we will have the best pair of hookers in SL within two seasons.

I don't think we lose much with Carlisle on to what we do with Withers. Hopefull he will improve similar to how Josh has over the last few years.

Has Kris Keating signed yet ?
I ask because i heard a whisper the club are exploring different options.

Supposed to be announced end of this week

Withers has been rubbish this year, lost the ability to make the big hits that he did last year, not that they were that effective anyway and his distribution and decision making have been terrible at times.

Agreed. His needless foul play cost us the game against Wigan.

Not playing to the standard expect this year at all, we are worse when he is on the pitch.

Been saying it for nearly two years.

On several usernames, obviously.