Craig Hall proved why he can never be relied upon to have a steady game, So up and down its unbelievable. He Never gifted them 1 try it was 2 directly by giving the ball to the oppo + some shocking last man defence which caused more. Caro did ok apart from the fumble for the try (didn't see it too clearly but looked like he tried to scoop it up rather than grounding it).

Keating is an odd one, I was calling him something rotten at the game but in hindsight and taking the no runners comment on board the it makes you wonder what has been practiced (if anything) in training. IF and it is an IF there where set moves with runners suposed to be there and Keating ran the play then is it clueless keating or clueless team. I noticed a number of times as he ran across the line he looked furious with his team mates after he'd been tackled. The kick through he did that wasn't chased!!! it does make you wonder.

hall gifted 2 and lets not pretend caro didn't knock on and the fact he was scared to catch the ball keating rubbish might as well give berrehal a go nothing to lose

James Graham was bigging him up as well. he is a hooker that you are playing at 7.

Keating's played second fiddle all year to Burns. However, when he does receive the ball, all I've seen is an inside pass/pop up to a forward. The only times he's looked any decent is his show/go close to the line. Resulted in most of his tries I'd imagine. With Burns in the bin, it was pretty obvious he had no options, but I'm still sure he was looking for an inside pass. His kicking too has been rank average all year. But has at least improved in the last few games (no longer pin point accuracy to waiting opposition backs). Our kick chase however, hasn't.

Salford looked to attack Caro's wing in the first half. With better handling I'm sure they'd have scored more. I like him, but at times he just looks all too easily exposed. He did drop a few catches too. His knock on/try was pretty bad. He didn't look to give himself much of a chance, such was his speed attacking the ball. Hard to call, with one view. But I sided with Child. With the new rule about deliberately grounding the ball, he didn't convince me he was trying to ground it/or achieved it. We'd more or less pressed the self destruct button by this point but Burns took care of that a few minutes later.

Interesting, the opta stas of yesterdays match show,keating made 7 more carries than travis,and made more than twice the metres travis did,are we being a bit harsh on him ?

Caro didn't ground the ball because he knocked it on. Despite what the majority of the east stand saw through their red and white tinted glasses.

Does that include running aimlessly across the field? ginners should be banned

Watching were you ?

no, why? Has he dyed his hair?

Nah, he knows nowt. Good painter though.

Does he have a beard and wears glasses ?

Can you tell who he is yet?

Saw the highlights yesterday on sky sports.
Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't there a new ruling on grounding the ball this year, in that you have to do ground the ball intentionally for it to be considered a drop out? It used to just be that all a player had to do was touch it which often caused problems when a player was trying to pick the ball up or if they slipped over while running in goal the ref would call a drop out .
from the highlights it looked Caro was trying to pick the ball up to return the kick and not actually trying to intentionally ground it. Seemed the correct call to me.

Caro knocked on end of