While they didn't all lead to points, Silverwood gave you 90% of the decisions this evening.

I don't believe he did, as 'dropped' is normally defined in that context. But it's gone and I've seen plenty of worse decisions.
For balance we got a try off a clear double movement against Wigan - and I regularly say 'WTF?' following VR decisions watching as a neutral. A lot of these things are very fine margins, and the official's opinion is the only one that matters.

The ball came out of his grasp before he went over the line. Whether you want to call it dropped or just that he lost control, fact is he didn't have a hold of it when he went over

Well for a neutral (or as neutral as an FC fan can be), I thought both teams gave as good a performance as they could in absolutely apalling conditions. As Dureau said at the end the ball was like a bar of soap.

Brilliant DG from dureau. Think rovers would probably have edged it if it weren't for the loss of 2 palyers

We should have kicked our penalties when we had the chance, that's what has lost us this game, our inability to kick a penalty.

Now I know you're just talking .

No problem at all with the last Catalan try.

KR had enough possession and territory to win the game, but not enough nous. Watch the game again.

On your board? We don't seem to bother much any more - odd snide comment on here, maybe. I'm discounting Les the Red, as he is so rubbish at trolling.



Neither of us can know, but I doubt it - why would the conditions make it more or less galling? You mean the fans were wet and cold as well as disappointed? Losing narrowly is painful for the what ifs and heartache, getting stuffed for the downbeat misery of it - I've felt much worse than this watching Rovers lose. 36-6 - that was galling!

No thanks!

Just looked at last try decision, and it's a bit harsh imo. The two best camera angles (in terms of frame rate) certainly suggested more of a no try rather than the other way round. The other angle has a rubbish resolution and totally misses the key frames. To base the decision on this one 'poor' angle is disappointing.

No point dwelling on this or other decisions though. So much goes for and against every team during 80 mins it's pointless.
We had so much possession and with it control, it sux to lose as we did. But it's gone now, Saints next week and we need to pick ourselves up.
Obviously the worst thing from tonight is the injuries. Let's hope for the best.

Agree with that.

shock

Robbed

Greendshields was a great finish. Master stroke putting him on the wing.

Loving how excited so many Hull fans are getting at this loss, and they try to make out were obsessed.....