Why don't you ask them to then?

The KC is the only TRUE stadium in SL and is one of the best grounds for atmosphere iv been there for wigan games and GB games and even when its not full you get an atmosphere.

Would you care to explain how you arrived at this conclusion? I'm keen to hear your fascinating theory.

I'd imagine he means all built up and fully enclosed??

The JJB is open in the corners wheras the KC is fully joined together all the way around??

Whats that got to do with it been a TRUE stadium though?
Dont get this one at all myself, i am confused

Is Anfield/St James Park/Goodison Park not a true football ground in that case? Or Camp Nou (one of the most famous sporting grounds ever) because its roof doesnt go all the way around? Or Stamford bridge because part of it is a hotel...

I could go on and on about stadiums like this.

But ill finish on this; If it is about RL stadiums that go all the way around and your suggesting the KC is the only one... I suggest you go and look at Doncasters KeepMoat.


P.S. nrls Suncorp Stadium

To be fair to him he did say that the KC is the only true stadium in SL which of course the Keepmoat isn't.

Apart from that he's still wrong though

Well seeing as though he said SLs only true stadium why would I need to go and look in Doncaster or Brisbane??

My mistake on that part then, but i would still like someone to explain how others arnt true SL stadiums?

Just because it goes all the way around doesnt make it a true stadium, Is the point i was trying to put forward.

I understand the "enclosed" part, but that isn't in my "true stadium" definition. You could argue that a "true RL stadium" would be one where only RL is played there, which tends to rule out most of the modern stadia in the country, as they are almost all multi-use these days.

The KC on derby days is a splendid sight and the atmosphere is up there with the best. However, from a view point alone, I prefer the DW, due to the rake angle of the away end affording you a better view. Just personal choice.

And as a traditionalist, give me Wheldon Road over the lot of 'em!

I understand it if thats his angle, but i still cant come up with a way were that would justify it to be a "true" stadium.
Out of the "newer" stadiums i would have to say my personal choice is HJ (Wires) because its up todate but still has the traditional feel with seats and standing.
DW has a great view (the best in my book)

It all goes on personal choice i suppose but for me, Craven park isnt a stadium, KC isnt a "true" RL SL stadium as it has football in it, so does DW.
So for me it would be HJ, as a stadium.

whilst i don't agree with this "true stadium" talk the halliwell jones has hosted international football and i'm pretty sure liverpool play their reserve games there.

I didnt know that but its not Liverpools ground is it, anfield is; The KC is Hull Citys ground & DW is Wigans ground. (im not saying they own it, im saying thats were they play there 1st grade home games)

International football as been played at Old Trafford doesnt mean its not Man Utds ground.

The main game played at the HJ is Rugby League - KC and DW have RL and Football as there main sports.

Wire moved liverpool reserves on at the start of last years footie season

fair enough i was just pointing out that the hj isnt exclusively for rugby league in fact quite a few modern stadia has had other sports/events played there.


ok thanks for info