Depends what way you look at it though, doesn't it. He's very good taking on the line and backing up, but his overall kicking game is pretty embarrassing for a top halfback. You'd be buggered if you just had him leading you around the park. Deepends what part of the respective players games you're refering to imo.

Yeah, ok then...

You might better remember him from his time with the Catalans, where he played under a slightly different name .... Meee-Kell Dob-Sun !

Have to agree about Newton he has been a bit of a letdown from what I expcted of him.

Dobson is what I have always said, a kicker and little else.

What I can't understand is why Cooke does not appear to be playing aswell as when he was at Hull, this is not a dig, just wndering why he does not grab hold of games like he did with us?

I thinks it looks like Cooke does not have a role to play and justin has given dobson all the comand. i think if you give cooke a chance to share the role he would do alot better and we will see the old Cooke

Is Cooke injured or was there another reason he didn't play on Friday.

Theres no doubt about that. Most SL squads would benefit from having Newton there, guess you just expect more from him.

wasnt dobson voted man of the match???

When your halves have played a half decent team (not one thats played 3 lost 3) come back and tell us how good yours are in comparison.

Too much Scotch is it mate or selective vision?

That said I'll have a double

Why? Surely you aren't telling me he was actually playing. I thought they were going to need a search party for him.

must have been his twin then that put the grubber in for briscoe's try then you div!