Dykes was a great half back .......The game he played against Wakefield in the semi-final of the Challenge Cup was superb and got Hull FC to the final, unfortunately he only played a few games a season because he was so injury prone .......Is this really the same scenario that we are hoping to build our team on?

Campese is a great half back that has the knowledge to organise the squad within a game and practice game management, but Matty Marsh will make more appearances within his role because he is less injury prone ........Is this really the scenario that we are comfortable with?

Basically, we don't have a regular, consistent and adequate half-back organiser right now .......Dobbo carried us for many years ......And presently we have hundreds of thousands of pounds that spends more time on the terraces and a youngster that would struggle to get into many of the Championship teams as our option at half-back .....How on earth do we think we will progress given this scenario?!?!

And, we have just given Matty Marsh a four year deal ......Deary me, why do we insist on signing players where we are keeping our fingers crossed? ......I maybe wrong, but do any of you really think Matty Marsh will develop into a half-back that could possibly lead us to winning silverware? .......Anybody?

In one word NO but he will be a good back up and maybe become good when he is older loads of players are late developers

If Wakey win today you're going to be 7 points off the top 8 with just 5 games left to the split. Even if Campese was fit again within a couple of weeks wouldn't it make sense to keep him back until the middle 8's start, giving him a better chance of lasting to the end of the campaign. This would IMO give you a better chance of retaining Super League status.

7 points behind Wakey, yes. 5 points off the top 8. (I don't believe we will make the 8 btw)

wakey won, Unless widness implode its the middles 8s, imo id wrap campese up for them,

No sh#t Sherlock

your coach thinks otherwise, but then hes not as clever as me,

We wrapped him in Cotten wool for the cats game. He lasted a game then went pop again. When he's fit play him.

Brian Mac still thinks leeds can get top 8

Webbo got slaughtered last year for being honest in the press about Wakey's need to focus on the middle 8's. He can't be as dumb as you are attempting to portray by not making the same mistake again.

whoooooose

Whose what?