Well after watching the Salford match, Percival was tackled in the same manner as Shenton last weekend. Percival has gone off injured with crutches. Shall we see what the outcome is!?!

Completely different scenario though where one man was tackling another who was running, not coming in as 3rd man when the tackle was already effected. They'll still probably ban him though to avoid the danger of flying dummies from east hull

Same referee as well.

Percival was being chase tackled moving forward and the player tackling from behind was swinging off the ground to halt his momentum until an additional impact front on with another tackler adds extra pressure on the knee when Percivals forward momentum is stopped. No malice, no intent, same type of tackle, similar unfortunate outcome, similar lack of reaction from the Saints players. Not put on report, nor should it have been.

I have been watching and supporting Rugby League since the mid 60s, seen this tackle thousands of times and seen hundreds of adverse injuries to player outcomes.

You are an idiot.

What are you on about? This tackle was very similar. Your black and white specs are steaming up, you'd best give them a wipe.

Has this been investigated by the Metropolitan police yet?

The sheer determination to abuse every post he puts up is beginning to amuse me after months and months of being bored and annoyed.

It really wasn't. Were you all rushing to sneyd's defence last season when he accidentally rolled maguire's ankle?

Absolutely no comparison in the two tackles but I thought at the time that some one on the HKR forum would try and justify Boudezbas tackle on Shenny by mentioning this.

I see we've found the real reason why you're in the minority here. So your basically just stirring the $hit because of something that happened last year that's burnt away at you all this time.

I think the main comparison is that in both a player ended up injured and neither were illegal challenges.

I beg to differ. The only outcome is Percival might miss a few matches, not a season. So shall we say.....2 games? Looking at it, the player tackled was very similar to last week. In other words, it was 'unfortunate' and 'not in the spirit of the game'. But a player is injured non the less, so let's up the grading and give a ridiculous ruling, and let that be the end of it.