Did you? I thought we were rubbish and deserved what we got but with 7 first teamers missing it's what you get.

As for your other bit, no I just use my own judgement. When was the last time you watched carney play and thought he was stand out?

didn't know you had players missing nobody has mentioned it before oops heres another one miloudi out with concusion after throwing the ball in touch

Carney was training with North Queensland and would of signed for them but nrl would not accept him so they must off seen something worth a try

In the unlikely event that he could reach his form of old he us top drawer.

In the likely event that he sporadically shows moments of genius, he is providing those moments for us in the middle 8s rather than Toronto, Widnes, Salford or leigh.

Leigh have to get in the middle 8s there not in the top 4

]
Leigh will probably scrape into the 4 with the way the fixtures are on Carney it’s a no brainier really we can’t take the risk of going into the 8s without back up for McGuire

Rover 2000, please dont go upsetting Jake, with your quick witted comments, he might not come back on here........

When was the last time you saw him play?

Not many players out there who can say they've been No1 in the world at some point

Come of it, he has never been the best halfback or fullback on the planet, even at the top of his game there was always 1 or 2 in front of him...

Good signing for you guys coming into the business end of the season, if nothing else at worst he provides good cover should DM pick up an injury.

2010 Dally M Medal winner???

And nsw and Australia international

If that's what counts as quick witted in your world I'd hate to see slow witted. He even had to have 2 goes at it

Can;t remember but it definitely wasn't in 2018

Amazing,you manage to criticise and rag anything rovers,you rag carney and ask when i last saw him have a good game,and you cant remember when you last saw him play.
You really are a plank,and in case you may think this a compliment,it isnt.