THE BEST SCRUM HALF IN SUPER LEAGUE

Quote: SmokeyTA "and these are the only criteria by which idiots judge a scrum half,

also would this be the 'creating more try' statistic that somehow has Ali Lauitiiti creating one try all season?

which surely shows the ridiculous the criteria for the albert goldthorpe medal is,

considering in both of its years a scrum half for a 'lesser' (note the inverted commas) team has won it, maybe the award in itself is weighted in favour of that type of player?

would this be the SL dream team which rated George Carmont as a better centre than Senior? and Ade Gardner as one of the best two wingers in SL

you are correct, they are very different players, Dobson in the Leeds team would offer nothing we dont already have from Sinfield and Mcguire,

Dobson is a much more traditional Scrum half who is more comparable to Long or Brough, Long is class act who dominates Saints, and they are going to miss him massively next year, Pryce (imo) is a nothing player at Stand Off, he is superfluous, he takes a winning saints from winning by ten points to winning by thirty but goes missing in close games, i woudl certainly go for long ahead of Dobson,

Brough is a different kettle of fish, depends on what you want, on his day brough is better and he doesnt seem to be phased by a big occassion, Dobson is more consistant, Brough can win a game single handedly and also be absolutely atrocious, Dobson needs a good workmanlike pack to be anything

i wouldnt have any of them in the leeds team though because they simply wouldnt fit into the way leeds play'"