No.

Saying Tilse is a waste of a quota place isn't exactly a glowing report especially seeing as he has been one of the better forwards in recent weeks

Apart from getting run over for the first try I thought he was very steady & did his job well certainly not rubbish, He is finaly finding his form & place in the team. There are certainly better imports but he is not to bad IMO.

Tilse has had 1 good game against saints the rest he has been poor

No he hasn't he's doesn't stand out but he's solid and very good in defence

Yeah, from what I've seen of Tilse this year, and I also thought and viewed with my own eyes last season he is decent defensively.

I couldn't get to Sunday's game as I'm forced to do things like spend time and go on holiday with Ms. Terrorista v.2 or it'll end up in litigation and extreme financial inconvenience to me, like Ms. Evil Terrrorista v.1. Poor planning also means that I miss The Derby, bad purchase of season ticket again.

As I said, I couldn't get to Sunday's game, but Tilse has been looking for the off load for the last few games, Roopy told us Campese would sniff around for those, he wasn't on the money to do it at Huddersfield, but the halves really, really need to get wise to this, it's a weapon we're singularly failing to exploit.

Watch Tilse. He looks to get his hands free at, every available opportunity, he often has the ball, but has to tuck it back as there's no option for him.

He's no panacea, but we're certainly under using him, and he should absolutely not be a scapegoat.

I'll be at Scarthin Books tomorrow.

He's a plodder at best, he runs half hearted, gets the odd offload away, gets brushed off tackles to easily like he did for there first try. Every now and again he'll have a really good spell where you think 'why can't he play like that all the time'
There must be plenty of props like that in the championship on half his wage.

All IMHO of course.

And my opinion to he started the game on Sunday and was absolutely shattered after 5 minutes and it wasn't till we got James green on we started to dominate all the props had good games except tilse hence why he had poor stints in the second half we were getting hammered for the first 10 minutes of the second half so webbo took tilse off and had to put green back on early and then tilse came back on with 6 minutes left to play, if we are defending a lead surely our most experienced prop that has played 200+ NRL games wouldn't sit out the whole second half?

You've just summed up Adam Walker this season in that post but no one is criticising him. As Sandro said Tilse big weapon is his off load but we so seldom back a prop up it doesn't get used enough. There have been far worse players this year than Tilse and if we're honest waste of cap currently is better leveled at a couple of other star players

I like Green he runs really hard but rarely breaks a tackle Tilse and Green are very similar but one gets slagged off constantly and the other is treated like some kind off god

We got physically dominated while tilse was on the pitch green came on and a few strong carries raised the crowd and the team, tilse is to soft people say his defence is good but it looks that way because opposition run at him because they know they can dominate him

I spoke to Dobbo after the game and he said Tilse was targeted because of his offloading. If you noticed, Salford committed 3-4 men in the tackle when Tilse carried - that has a tiring effect on both the player and the opposition - and it also provided space at acting half which French John and Lawler did to great effect.

Regarding Green, Dobbo said they know he isn't going to offload or play the ball quickly, which surprises him seeing how Greeny was known for it when he captained the academy.