agree completely that if players need to improve then the reserve grade is NOT the place for them......a spell in the rough,tough world of championship footy will do them no harm whatsoever........its a good yardstick to run the rule over wether they can mix it when it really means something Ie win bonuses etc etc.....
in my opinion, superleague teams should have a sister club in the champ-ionship/second league wereas they could blood there youngsters and also take there youngsters on trial etc etc etc...win-win for me....

I'm not sure, and hoping that someone will enlighten me here, but isn't this how the new dual registration thing will work?

As far as Watts goes, yes, I think the lad has definitely got talent but he needs a serious kick up the proverbial and to start to realise that potential.
Sport at this level entails that everybody is super fit and firing on all twelve cylinders, therefore it becomes 10% physicallity, 20% talent and 70% mental fortitude and application. Only Liam can answer whether he's got that fire in his belly to succeed.

Guess his opportunities may be limited depending who else you bring in. If you dont bring any front rowers in he may get more game time than anticipated to stake his claim.

Could be a make or break season for him, personally I'd send him to a Championship club for the first 1/3 of the season, then give him a handful of 1st team games later in the year.

isn't that the point of the new age competitions?

cant players, like haynes, get called back at a moments notice?

Thats right. The whole idea was for the parent club to have greater control over their contracted player.

It makes me laugh that fans of Super Dooper League clubs just expect to be able to palm off their young reserves on 'top Championship' clubs who should be over the moon they have been given such talent

Take a look at the squads of the top 4/5 Championship clubs and you will find most players are ex Super League and if not established Championship level players. Why the hell would Widnes, Halifax, Barrow or Fev want any of those players you mentioned?

Liam Watts is supposed to be the best thing since sliced bread according to this thread and he was sent to Gateshead last year, a side who would of stayed up by the skin of their teeth.

It is an insult to the players playing Championship Rugby that people just think Super League clubs reserves should walk into their team!!

They would probably struggle to get into York's team at the moment. Donny however would snap your hand off looking at the shizzle they have signed this year

I wouldn't believe a word David Howes says...

Liam looked very promising when he came to us, im still hopefull of big things from him, hopefully hell get a good bit of game time to aid his development,
id sooner play him then Mills, and maybe even Netherton too.

How has he looked since he came over to you? we never got to see much of him at cas, but i hope he goes on to do very well for himself.

looked promising in 2008 in the handful of games he played, but did not feature last year and went on loan to Gateshead and seeing him play on sky against sheffield(i think), felt he appeared to have gone backwards!!

Just do that dual thing Leeds have done, im sure its for the purpose of bringing them back should they be needed.