before catalans was inroduced it was muted for a couple of years by sky about expanding and introducing a french team and voila what happened all of a sudden a french team. who was also given a franchise for 3 years and had no fear of relegation even though they finished bottom in there first year..

because of sky celtic are in at the expense of a eststablished team

and all of a sudden the move mm to scotland and now they say it would be good to get a scottish team so again how long before his happens?

franchising is another one that should not of been brought in as it leaves teams near the bottom with nothing to play for but pride whereas relegation makes teams fight just that little bit harder, as we know from our 2007 season, and just what have celtic brought to the table ,if i`m not mistaken by far the worst team to ever grace the super league as i cannot recall a team winning less games or scoring less points , they have been rushed in and where nowhere near ready both on or off the field, hence the rfl stepping in now in there first year to give them a helping hand.

I actually thought it was for the pass before the last pass and Silverwood was just late with his whistle .

Well in that case it DEFINITELY wasn't forward.

It is not because of Sky, don't become one of the conspiracy theorists. Catalans wasn't muted for a few years by Sky, they were CONFIRMED entry by the RFL in 2002, which is why it was being discussed for the following years. Nothing to do with Sky.

If it wasn't for Sky, Hull KR (and Hull FC) wouldn't be where we are anyway, playing at the standard they do in the stadia they're in so I don't see what your problem is.

Stevo is alive and well and living in west Hull.

Lets lock this at the end of the day is was a blatant forward pass that is not allowed.

Even if the try had stood, it would have only got you a draw (assuming it had been converted which would not have been a "gimme"icon_wink.gif. Why not attribute some of your sour grapes on Whiting for bombing a "certain" try with the line at his mercy?

This was our poorest home performance of the season and you were still not good enough to win. Look at your own coaching staff and players for blame, they had enough chances to win the game, yet didn't.

At the end of the day, no FC players surrounded Silverwood to berate him for a wrong decision. Enough said.

First of all Raynor would have gone under the sticks as he had clear run.

Secondly, you scored off the set following the scrum for the forward pass. Had the try stood you wouldn't have had the ball to score the try.

Thirdly, Whiting didn't "bomb a certain try" it was actually very good work by Fox (who has impressed me this season) to make that extra effort to get back and dislodge the ball.

Fourthly, this is rugby not football. The players shouldn't be surrounding the ref to berate him and the fact you think they should if they feel hard done by probably shows why Justin thinks he can say whatever the hell he wants about referees.

What does robinho's opinion have to do with Justin Morgan's actions?

I'm applying the universal law of forums and assuming the opinion of one fan represents the vast majority of Rovers fans and therefore suggesting that a culture of abusing referees exists at Rovers, hence Justin thought his outburst was justified. Simplez.

Simplez, but nonetheless nonsenz.

right for arguments sake, lets say you got that forward pass, you still had a try in the first half that shouldn`t have been, cordoba pushed dobson in the back with two hands which resulted in dobson kneeing the ball dead, the result from this was a goal line drop out when in fact it should of been a penalty as attackers are not allowed to push defenders in that way...... and in the first set from the drop you scored a try......


you win some you lose some, we can debate decisions till the cows come home but at the end of the day the result will still stand and nothing can be done about it now

aint this sport just brill