What use would another below average, past it half back be?

If he'd replaced Manu or Chello for you he'd have been a great signing. Take your blinkers off . Has the size and nasty streak we aee lacking.Would walk into any pack in SL. Agree his form has dipped and the incident won't have helped him but a fresh start with us suits both parties.

I don't think many Hull fans would be happy if he replaced Mini or Manu. You only have to look on the Wigan forums to see how they rate him.

On a possibly related matter Rovers are due make an announcement soon confirming the release from contract of another player. Speculation it could be either Heffernan or Carney.

Short memories eh hull fans??? Since when were Hull FC the purveyors of moral behaviour in rugby league? #JamesRuleDrugsMule

no surprise there carney is at the back end of his playing days and Heffernan will cut short a promising, if short career

A worse incident? Are you living in cuckoo land?

Might go alright for us but is a proper bell end.
Hull KR don't represent my personal moral compass, I can knack that up on my thanks.
At the moment we need proven players and although he's not been as good since coming back from Onion he unfortunately will add to the squad, which shows where we are. We knew this.
People who need an exterior agency to represent how great they are as a person are usually using it as a cover for their own misgivings.

Sad as it is, in every sense, coming in at 6 and 5 on my season highlights have been Albert Kelly being outed as a bellend and the reaction to it of most Hull fans on here, respectively.

So, I’ll take this opportunity to unequivocally condemn Tomkin’s words and actions on his video. The punishment dished out by Wigan felt appropriate for the amount of shade he brought on them.

A poor version of Danny Tickle. Pathetic signing.

I'm sure Tomkins will perform better then Danny Tickle in the 8s

He really wouldn't. He's been dire since he returned from union. He hasn't even been a starter for wigan and they've been playing one of their back rowers at centre all year. I'd have been disappointed if we'd signed him

Tomkins or Kellys behaviour both unacceptable so the FC fans stating which is the more Moronic is unbelievable, so why dont you all take a walk back to the darkside, and you Jake, hobble back on your peggy, bye......