I would have Dave Hodgson at full back (untill Cockayne is fit) as at least he can catch a ball & unlike Hall & Caro he is decisive & wont leave it to another. I dont know how the youngsters are going enough to coment on them. Eden should play but if he is messing about off field the lets get rid now.

Have you ever seen hodgsons one and one tackling? I'm not saying I have in precisely but I've seen it enough to know I don't trust him at full back!

Learn from FCs error in appointing Radford, Chester is not the solution

Personally I would give Chester the opportunity on a minimum 2 yr deal. The man has served his time and deserves a chance and a chance to have some impact on the quality and quantity of players we need to attract and tie down to the club. I imagine there will be quite a number of personnel changes next year, both on and off the pitch and whoever we have next needs to be given as much time as possible to stamp their own mark on the job. Its a fantastic opportunity for someone. I for one hope its Chris Chester.

Thing is 3 games into his tenure the team throw the towel in against a team we are battling with for 8th. Doesn't bode well with me for his authority and presence.

chester was a smart player and I think he'll make a good coach. Far more chance of him doing it than radford

I take your point and am not naive enough to think that any coach is every players cup of tea.I just think that given the amount of time hes spent as assistant the guy deserves a bit of respect and a chance to prove himself. If the players throwing the towel in don't want to play for him or any HKR coach then they don't deserve to be called professional sportsmen and all the prestige that goes with it. The same players stuck 40 on Saints in his first game.Gentles defeat at Huddersfield and the apparent player power to oust him has done little for the west side and if the same culture happens here then three season passes are going straight in the bin.

If he was assistant at a club with great discipline and some success, yeah, he'd deserve a shout. However, he's been at the club right through alongside the problems and shortfalls.

Probably a bit optimistic but I'd be finding out what Anthony Griffin's plans are.

He shouldn't be our new coach but he will be. I'm massively in favour of a clear out of staff. Matt Parish is now available. He's renound as a disciplinarian.

And the eden incident is since he took charge.

Get rid of mallinson as well

What's he done to upset you?

Nothing, the team are in great condition.

I don't see the logic of your statement. Why should Radford's apparent failure have any bearing on any appointment made at our club?