Is that you Peter Kay?

Most over rated player in the SL IMO but Wigan fans think the sun shines out of his backside.

And the last 3 x GB/England coaches who've all selected when fit!
In Wigan's Top 3 players EVERY Week and Best 13 in comp (Onoy SInfield can challenge him for me but I would have O'Loughlin).

That means everything then.


Seeing as the likes of Calderwood also got selected for a trip down under for the World cup.

One of the best defenders in SL!

I think that O'loughlin is the best 13 in the Comp although this is likely to change with Dallas Johnson here.

it amazes me when fans can't see the defensive work some players put in, if it isn't a big hit then they don't see it. Jon Clarke at Wire is the same, nowt special going forward but nothing gets past him in defence.

he put in 50+ tackles, distributed well and scored a try.

Not bad for over rated.

Id agree with that.
I still maintain he is over rated though for his all round game and nothing will change that opinion.

But you originally said this



Maybe because we see those35-40 tackles every week means we appreciate what he does and that's why we like him?
Plus his double figure tries every year, his countless try assists & his pretty good kicking game.

Not seen enough of Dallas Johnson, but outside that he's the best 13 in the comp for me.

But despite that you don't think he's any good? I wonder who's opinion I should listen to then!

Look at all Emile Heskey's England Caps.
Coaches get it wrong you know in every sport