I don't think it should be 'hes a world beater, must keep him, disgrace if we let him go' or 'hes rubbish good riddance'.
Hes a decent SL prop, not been great this season but has shown in glimpses he's capable of more just needs to find more consistency. He's at the age where he needs to start showing more in terms of development, maybe under anew coaching set up he would. Plus we've spent years and £ developing it would be annoying if we said no thanks off you go and then he started tearing it up somewhere else.
That said, it all comes down to how much he wants. Our cap management has been a travesty and he's not worth paying over the odds for, not that we would ever know these demands or how much we offer him. I can't see him getting and Nrl gig if he does I imagine it will be 2nd grade couple of years living in Oz thenback over here.
I'd like us to attempt to keep him, make him a decent offer 2/3 years. If he doesn't develop much more he's still a decent non quota squad player, if he does then great good business to keep him. It's not easy to replace players these days, quality homegrown players are pretty scarce and huge overturn of players isn't healthy (seems inevitable given this year's debacle) but if seems sensible to try and minimise it as much as possible

I always get slated by fellow fans where I stand for saying the same thing. You can also throw in that he doesn't play many minutes.

Since Justin Morgan left the club we haven't improved any players. The board need to get the right coach this time or we're going to keep going backwards.

I reckon Josh Hodgson would disagree with you.

What the kid who Hull fans said wouldn't make it in the NRL the same Josh Hodgson who's leading the Dally M points that one