Massive to have Josh back , he was excellent also.

Shaw was terrific but Tilse was rubbish what game was you watching

Try reading my post properly,I said shaw was terrific and tilse was a waste of a quota space,which is exactly what I posted.Specsavers may be able to help.

Looking forward to the derby des ?

No.

Saying Tilse is a waste of a quota place isn't exactly a glowing report especially seeing as he has been one of the better forwards in recent weeks

Apart from getting run over for the first try I thought he was very steady & did his job well certainly not rubbish, He is finaly finding his form & place in the team. There are certainly better imports but he is not to bad IMO.

Tilse has had 1 good game against saints the rest he has been poor

No he hasn't he's doesn't stand out but he's solid and very good in defence

Yeah, from what I've seen of Tilse this year, and I also thought and viewed with my own eyes last season he is decent defensively.

I couldn't get to Sunday's game as I'm forced to do things like spend time and go on holiday with Ms. Terrorista v.2 or it'll end up in litigation and extreme financial inconvenience to me, like Ms. Evil Terrrorista v.1. Poor planning also means that I miss The Derby, bad purchase of season ticket again.

As I said, I couldn't get to Sunday's game, but Tilse has been looking for the off load for the last few games, Roopy told us Campese would sniff around for those, he wasn't on the money to do it at Huddersfield, but the halves really, really need to get wise to this, it's a weapon we're singularly failing to exploit.

Watch Tilse. He looks to get his hands free at, every available opportunity, he often has the ball, but has to tuck it back as there's no option for him.

He's no panacea, but we're certainly under using him, and he should absolutely not be a scapegoat.

I'll be at Scarthin Books tomorrow.

He's a plodder at best, he runs half hearted, gets the odd offload away, gets brushed off tackles to easily like he did for there first try. Every now and again he'll have a really good spell where you think 'why can't he play like that all the time'
There must be plenty of props like that in the championship on half his wage.

All IMHO of course.