I disagree, maybe a slight improvement but he is still very vulnerable. Although that doesnt concern me really you expect a halfback to be weak defensively, anything else is a bonus. Its his attacking play thats disappointing and he needs to improve

It is getting embarrassing in the east stand I remember when we used to get behind the team and no one is saying you can't question a decision but this victim mentality is cringing for instance I never heard a murmur when Craig Hall knocked on and we got the decision if Gardners try had been scored in the same way by a Huddersfield player we would have been up in arms we seem to have more songs about the refs and the rfl now

I'll still give keating time, burns was an also ran last year and I think it takes a year to settle in a team for a half back. We dont want to turn into fc and throwing away good half backs too early.

see how he progresses next year then judge him

You really are the voice of reason. There'll be lots on here who won't like what you're saying.

As much as I agree with other posters about how poorly a scrum half Keating is. I agree more with the above.

I totally agree, I actually think he's not that bad, in a steady rather than spectacular sort of way, lets face it he had massive boots to fill in Dobbo, and who ever we got for the role was always in a no win situation.