Overly harsh when the whole team were dreadful. Even if he'd dived there was no guarantee he'd score and we should never have been in that position int he first place. The more game time he gets the better he'll be. I recall the darkside coming out with this rubbish every time Craig Hall had a bad day and he's one of our most consistent performers.

No wonder you're rubbish then

Eden was directly at fault for three tries and bombed at least one.

To be fair to caro he's still young and the team shud not have been in a position for a last gasp try to win when we were 20 points in front and in the driving seat, I think panic took over and I'm sure once he looks back on it he will realise, it's not just down to caro I'm afraid.

I admire people defending him but the bombed try at the end was some of the worst wing play I've ever seen! Totally bottled it,made worse by fact he's 6.4ish bout 15stone. Not a overly difficult scoring opportunity.

Sums him up. Caro has all the physical attributes to be a top quality player but he doesn't have the mentality to be a Rugby League player. He is reasonable in open space but timid in the collision. Having the ball is a massive hinderance to him - I remember once he had an open break to the try line at Gillingham but somehow got chased down by Danny Tickle IIRC (certainly an FC forward) even though he had a ten yard start.

Defensively he is poor especially in his positioning - this is something that seems to be common amongst our youngsters and I'm not too sure why it is.

Not good enough for you, would slip in nicely amongst our rabble though.

Caro is a bottleless pile of shat

Caro & Eden both young & lacking experiance, they will only be proved poor if they keep making the same mistakes. Lets be truthfull neither would have been first choice if Shannon Mcdonald had stayed & Burns was available, we have a young inexperianced squad & we will keep getting daft results like yesterday untill they get the experiance. For me the one posative was our both played well.

I agree and I also think these two will improve as the season goes on (hopefully)

Why Caro didn't dive is beyond me - it should be instinctive - and really he should have dived in for the earlier try but elected to run it in but got away with that one. . .just.

I don't think it is a case of not having 'bottle', its more a case of him taking the wrong option. I am sure CS and his coaching staff train this option into him during his period of reflection (sounds better than being dropped).

As already alluded to by a few posters, Caro's run in the team will come to an abrupt end against Warrington, which was always going to be the case once Travis Burns became available.

Just how anyone can tell how Caro and Eden will turn out is beyond me ! Both are young and learning the game and will make mistakes.
Eden made some errors but the winning try wasnt his fault,it was a wicked bounce of the ball !
Support the young players,they need it,what they dont need is slagging off.IMO of course !
Thought Keal played ok but then when Josh came back on we went backwards,strange how it was the opperste last week but that didnt matter as much coz we won !