if hes played in his best position i see no reason why we wont have ourselves 3 very good in our first team squad, time will indeed tell

Like I said, Never really looked out for him to honestly say he was weak in defence or such but reading some of your lot pointing out his weaker attributes I've looked out for it, been good so far in a Rovers jersey.

Once or twice, and didn't look out of place IMO. But then I'm a fan of his.

His defensive frailties were exaggerated IMO, although there's no denying he did put in some poor performances. Didn't help that he was playing on our right side where our edge defence is suspect regardless of who plays there. His defence also suffers a lot when his confidence drops.

I'd be inclined to stick with Hall because he's had a good couple of games and if he doesn't play we won't have a goal kicker.