see your point, Seymour played brilliantly, looked like he was playing his own natural game of covering the whole pitch instead of just one side, excellent distribution, maybe Horne to 1 and Brough to 6 if we managed to get him, Brough's pace and kicking could add a lot but yeah Huddersfield wouldn't just let him walk I reckon

Getting Brough back to us would be as massive as signing Ellis imo because of what he brings to the team. Dont see it happening though

i dont think hull are expecting to get him for free, but if brough turns round and tells huddersfield he wants to leave they know they cant expect to get top dollar for him

It's not to spite anyone, but any game time he has now will ultimately benefit Saints. Put Martin in and rotate him with Crooks to develop him for next year.

Gentle n co did say the master plan was to bring in top English players so maybe Broughy isnt as leftfield as some on here are making out. think he would have a more noticeable impact for us then Finch

Where are people getting the idea that Brough would love to come back to Hull? If anything why would he want to leave Huddersfield?

because Brown's going?

Only what I've been told but due to the circumstances regarding his departure Brough has nothing but distain for Hull Football Club. Again only what I've been told but Finch is the wanted target long with another forward whom I'm told is a done deal.

Was Broughs own doing wasnt it,acting the silly get with Sharp

Losing 2 players we want to keep to one of our rivals can't be a good thing

Happens all the time though.Ellis is a replacement for Manu and Arundel/Crooks for Turner......are we really losing out.Manu may hurt us coming back but cant see Turner doing it.

You miss the point. Hull wanted both players in addition to those you mention. they now have to go and find replacements who will either not be as good or will cost more

May well of been but I still believe his departure was less than amicable.

So do we only play players we know for definite are going to be at the club for the following season? That could get complicated.

In the grand scheme of things any extra 'development' that either Manu or Turner get over the rest of the season is hardly going to benefit Saints that much, and not fielding our best 17 every week will hurt us more. Players have to be picked on form - anything else is plain daft.

How do you know they wont be as good.We did want both players to stay and offerd 1 )Manu) what he wanted but he has turned us down,nothing we can do there and Turner wants to go back to Lancashire.