No we didn't. We only scored 50 points once during sharpe's tenure and that was in his 1st game. We were predicatable under him and won many games by defending well rather than scoring lots of points

So Sharp sorted the defence out....thought that was the whole idea.....what would you sooner have.....38-36 scorelines or 18-4 ones....know which one i prefer.

Last time we hit 50 in a S/L game was in 2006 UNDER Sharps tenure against Wigan...we had plenty of 30's and 40's under his regime.....bet Agar would love to be able to do that.

Apart from the drubbing at home by Rovers, we played some good rugby with Head in the team.

We won 9 from 12 and scored 40+ three times in four games. In comparison in 2008 we only scored 40+ twice (aside from against Rochdale in the cup) In 2009 we never scored more than 40 at all and only scored [i30+[/i twice.

Good thing them history results on Hulls website......we also hit the frogs for 30 as well before them 3 40+ games......End of the day...Sharp had the defence sorted and the attack wasnt too shabby either

True. In 2004 we may have put big scores on very poor super league teams but we always came short when it mattered. Something often overlooked.

I would take a team that knows how to win the big games anyday personally.

2004 team hit a worse injury run than agar has had otherwise looked likely grand finalists

I'd love a team which knows how to win big games. Which one do you suggest?

Injury excuses eh? Sounds familiar.

I would say the Challenge Cup winning team of 2005 found a way to win the big games as opposed to their predecessors!

To a lesser extent the 2006 vintage got their way to Old Tafford and in 2008 we got to Wembley. As said the 2004 team lost every 'big' game they played - Saints in the Challenge cup and Wakey at home in the play offs.

Harsh but true excuses or not.

So if they saw the light and binned agar you'd welcome sharp back then with him being such a good coach?

I personally wouldnt take Sharp back at all but then I would never argue against his record of taking Hull FC to their only Grand Final in the Super League era. His signings and bad luck after this determined his future IMO.

I don't think there is a single Saints fan who wants Sharp as our next coach.

Apparently there are a dozen contenders and our Chief will announce who has the dubious privilege of getting the job in July. I hope that whoever it is, is a gifted coach, actually has a personality and can also wear shades in a sexy fashion.

Would you take Agar?