No.

Modern day Physio's are hugely different to those of even 5 or 6 years ago, never mind 10 years ago. I would expect any professional physio to be able to give a reasonable prognosis, but following that, and taking into consideration that they are dealing with professional sportsmen, I would expect that the club would follow this up with expert opinion, to enable the physio, in conjunction with doctors/medical team to diagnose a course of remedial therapy and or recovery.

The physio's job is not one of just diagnosis, it is also to manage the injury and to ensure that the player gets the best and most appropriate treatment and that said player maintains this throughout the recupperation period. I think it harsh to wholly blame the physio for an incorrect prognosis, although if having identified the injury, the physio prescribes the wrong treatment then there is a case to answer.

Another consideration is that if the physio prescribes a course of treatment and the player/injury doesn't respond, then who is to blame, afterall we hear frequently of players not looking after themselves i.e. M O'M, JE, etc. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make it drink and its always easier to blame a third party for your own failings, which I know some of our more UTOA's players are prone to do. Professional sportsmen and women, including our own players, have a duty to look after their own health, if for what ever reason they are reluctant to do so, then the physio, who is some way down in the management system, can hardly be blamed.

Good post, what does UTOA's mean?

Go on have a stab at it

UTOA is an acronym used by a small faction of Hull FC players, standing for 'Underground Team Of Addicts'.

It's a reference to O'Meley's smoking addiction, Turner's toffee crisp addiction, McKinnon's addiction to females and Burnett's addiction to blaming the physio.

Makes more sense than anything I could come up with.

I was thinking along the lines of 'Up Their Own Arris's'

Has any one heard these rumours ?

Tickle fined by gentle for photo of him drinking after exiles match ?
Tickle has again asked be allowed to leave at end of season ?
Moa 3 year deal at wigan ( I would be devestated if this one was true) ?

Only heard that one today on here. Hope it's not true after he said he'd either stay at Hull or go back to the NRL. I can't see that he would sign a three year deal anyway - he's supposed to be homesick, isn't he?

Rock God X, I noticed that on a couple occasions after Hull had scored @ Wakefield, whilst the rest of the team met together in the middle of the pitch Sam Moa just walked to his allotted spot prior to the re-start. I thought then that something may not be ok. Like you, I would be disappointed should he remain in this country & play for another team.

That was my first thought too . If he did go to another sl club I dont think it would go down well with the fans . But its only RUMOURS and I hope it stays that way tbh

If he goes to another SL club I wouldn't blame him, I would blame the people at FC for not being able to retain him, the more I hear the more I believe there are problems at FC, time will tell.